Amy should have just binned him.
There was no need for the list, there was no need to say you didn't like me. There was no point going through the whole list just to say "I need a break, I'm not saying it's over"
Also why was she saying it was perfect if he wasn't cuddling her in the mornings? Or never said she was beautiful?
I'm glad he ended it. I think she came across as a bit desperate.
I think he just knew he wanted to dump Amy and was too cowardly to do it, ever since the snogging competition.