X Factor Frankie is being replaced by....

[tefal]

Johnjo, 2 shoes, Amelia or James.

Public Vote on Saturday.

Can remember Johnjo, 2 shoes & Amelia, but not James?

Shame he can't be replaced by the Risk.

why those ones?? seems it would be fairer to let it be johnnie or the risk
out of those i would rather 2 shoes probably! but have not missed any of those acts

Officials are saying because those 4 were never voted out by the public (you will remember the 4 judges voted one out from each of their gategories) on the first night then the public should decide who gets another shot. James was in Gary's crowd.

What about Jade?

Everyone loved her.

Why hasn't she made the cut?

[cynical]

X factor is so weird this year. I would go with 2 shoes I think. But James was verh pretty

Jade never made it to the live shows - much to my disgust!

Sorry, voting seems to start tomorrow with one of the 4 back on Saturday for the live shows.

No, that's what I mean.

Surely all who were kicked out at Judge's Houses should be given tha same opportunity?

But those 4 were picked for the live shows but possibly yes, that would be a better idea. In fact, I like it!

I love James and thought his take on the Beatles song was fantastic.

it's all a load of b but I still watch it. The Risk obviously have a deal already so thats why they went, Johnnie doesn't really have the x factor and Frankie...... well not sure what the deal was there at all. Its all well thought out before hand fix factor

Were they?

Oh sorry, I'm out of touch then.

Yes beyond. They got through to the live shows but the judges voted them out on week 1.

I think James is pretty too

I did like 2shoes for the comedy factor but doubt they'll get voted in.

I bet Amelia gets voted in though, she was rubbish and wore too much make up! and slept with Frankie STD apparently!

i fricking luffed jade, the xf tried to get her to change who she was - cover tattoos, take out piercings etc - and i think she would have hated to be on the show eventually tbh.

out of the four to choose from i say amelia or barrys boy, was he the chavvy paolo nutty? i liked them both ver much. 2 shoes are updiffed and jonjo god love him couldnt hold a steady note.

I think the reason they may be doing this, is that it didn't go to public vote with them, so no money was spent. To decide to re-instate someone from Sunday- who has been through the public vote, would mean probably refunding all the voters who would be pissed off their vote didn't count. So, in a warped, weirdy way, it is fair...i think

I'm surprised Tulisa isn't putting them all together to form yet another new group.

Would be so funny if whoever gets voted into Saturday's show went on to win it. Not sure it would happen given the choices but would show those 'judges' up big time!

I agree about it being cause they don't want to refund money. After all the problems with phone votes over the years they have to keep the integrity

To bring in someone from the beginning in Week 6 seems a tad odd. Give Johnny a chance! He was kept in by the public vote until last week, people love him and it was unfortunate he was in the sing off at all. The Risk had the lowest amount of votes so should have gone imo.

I hope it's that lovely young man with the hat.

Amelia Lily, if only to make her feel better after contracting whatever horrific disease from Cockoozer.

2 shoes lady will be quite advanced on her pg now, no?

It'd be splendid for 2shoes to go on and prove that pg women can do actual stuff

and I can live vicariously through her as I shuffle grumpily around with my enormo-bump and rickety pelvis

I am officially a lost cause.

all 4 of my 'threads I'm on' are X Factor related.

I'm nearly 40 ffs.