DH is convinced that the whole thing is in Jack's head. (he's in a coma or something)
My sister told me that the original idea was that they were all dead or in purgatory but as everyone jumped to that conclusion they changed it.
I was wondering if, when Charlie said, all they wanted was Claire, did he mean out of the two of them? Or from the plane? Did they cause the plane to crash? Could French woman have been pg when they were shipwrecked and now they've taken her baby too?
Too many questions, sorry