Please or to access all these features

Teenagers

Parenting teenagers has its ups and downs. Get advice from Mumsnetters here.

DS wants to leave school

66 replies

Teawithfrenchtoast · 12/11/2026 14:35

My DS is almost 17 and is in S6 at school (Scotland). He’s decided that he’s had enough of school and wants to leave. He has a rosey idea of taking a year to himself, no schooling or college/uni and just working his existing weekend job. He would like to eventually join the forces but not for a year or two.

He’s completely disengaged at school, he skips classes with his friends and has told his teachers and guidance teacher that he has no intention of sitting any prelim exams in January, so school quite rightly are questioning why he is still enrolled there. He brought home a leavers form for us to sign a few weeks ago however I haven’t signed it - he also knows that he technically doesn’t need our permission to leave as he’s in S6. We have told him that we’ll agree to him leaving school if he has a mid week job, is in further education or has his application in for which ever force he wishes to join - he feels we are being unreasonable and are preventing him from being his own person and living his own life.

I am really concerned that he’ll leave school and waste his days sleeping in until late afternoon. He does this during school holidays. We live rurally and there is very little public transport. He can’t take driving lessons until he’s 17, and will then obviously need to learn to drive, pass his test and get a car. His friends live in different villages. DH and I both work so can’t ferry him round during day times. He’s not interested in looking for a mid week job as he again has a rosey view of just applying for the forces and breezing the assessments etc - he will not listen to reason about how mentally and physically challenging it can be during the application and training process, and it’s certainly not guaranteed that he’d get in, however I don’t doubt his abilities and do think once he’s in, he’d flourish.

im feeling at a loss with him. Its getting to the point where school will ask him to leave and he will be delighted to do so, but will then be bored still, jobless (apart from weekends) and nocturnal. He can’t just spend a year or two lazing about with no guarantee of a future career.

OP posts:
wildnwilde · 12/11/2026 17:05

would he consider Harrogate foundation college . My son went at 16 was the best thing he ever did . Earning 1550 pm from day 1 lives down south now at 23 still serving . I think if you want to join forces putting it off is one of the worse things you can do from experience. My daughter put it off and was probably a stronger candidate than my son it’s her biggest regret as life and friends took over . My son is now 15 school was doing him no favours the plan going fed is home ed cadets , and MPCT in sept with a view to joking Harrogate march 28 intake . I’d push him hard to do something or active if he’s set on forces the sooner the better .

wildnwilde · 12/11/2026 17:06

Teawithfrenchtoast · 12/11/2026 16:54

There is an access to uniformed services course at college however the next course will run from August next year.

we have suggested the cadets but they meet in the evenings.

These are fab places also handy for police fire service etc . It’s a chance to learn the basics and get fit as well as doing functional skills .

LiberteLynx · 12/11/2026 17:10

Teawithfrenchtoast · 12/11/2026 16:20

We took him for an appt at the forces careers office a few months ago. He was hyped up and wanted to join, then suddenly decided he would join in a year or two instead so he could have a year to himself…we did give him a reality check that having a year to yourself doesn’t exist unless you’re extremely wealthy or have a firm, realistic and fully funded plan.

I think it is great he wants to join the forces, but has he considered that even in the forces your career progression requires educational attainment? If he is thinking of joining the officer corps at any point in the next twenty years, he should spend the next year or two getting advanced highers.

MrsMoastyToasty · 12/11/2026 17:11

Does he know what trade within the forces he wants to do? Eg catering, engineering, musician (we have a family member who joined the Scots Guards as a bagpiper).
It might be worth doing a related job (or volunteering) in a related field for the year. It might stand him in good stead when he applies.

Perhaps taking fitness courses or learning to be a fitness instructor is an option.

Teawithfrenchtoast · 12/11/2026 17:12

wildnwilde · 12/11/2026 17:05

would he consider Harrogate foundation college . My son went at 16 was the best thing he ever did . Earning 1550 pm from day 1 lives down south now at 23 still serving . I think if you want to join forces putting it off is one of the worse things you can do from experience. My daughter put it off and was probably a stronger candidate than my son it’s her biggest regret as life and friends took over . My son is now 15 school was doing him no favours the plan going fed is home ed cadets , and MPCT in sept with a view to joking Harrogate march 28 intake . I’d push him hard to do something or active if he’s set on forces the sooner the better .

This is what I’m hoping he chooses to do, so I am keen for him to get his application in now as they only have intakes in March and Sept. He’s undecided between Marines and the Army, my preference would be army as there are many different training and career opportunities - not the same with the marines. However he’s had his head turned by the Marines being seen as an elite force, but honestly I don’t think he’d pass the mental and physical endurance training of the marines at 17! It’s hard! He could join the army, gain experience and in years to come do the All Arms course and transfer to the marines if that’s his ultimate goal…but he doesn’t want to do that purely because DH and I think it’s best for him.

OP posts:
Dandeloosha · 12/11/2026 17:12

My DS wanted to take a ‘gap’ year after A levels. I told him I’d have no trouble with that as long as he was working, volunteering, or travelling. The one thing he absolutely was not doing was lying around all day gaming and sleeping. If he wanted to do that he could move out because I wasn’t finding a lazy, unproductive, life - in our house everyone does something and everyone has a purpose. Lo and behold, Little Johnny bounced off to university with a spring in his step 😂

wildnwilde · 12/11/2026 17:13

LiberteLynx · 12/11/2026 17:10

I think it is great he wants to join the forces, but has he considered that even in the forces your career progression requires educational attainment? If he is thinking of joining the officer corps at any point in the next twenty years, he should spend the next year or two getting advanced highers.

Edited

Depends what you want to do. The army offers so many opportunities for further education and skills . No formal education isn’t the end of the world . Obviously if he has his heart set on certain roles some form of results may be required but it’s certainly not essential .

Newname26 · 12/11/2026 17:14

LiberteLynx · 12/11/2026 17:10

I think it is great he wants to join the forces, but has he considered that even in the forces your career progression requires educational attainment? If he is thinking of joining the officer corps at any point in the next twenty years, he should spend the next year or two getting advanced highers.

Edited

Advanced Highers is a one year course.

Scotland has Highers & Advanced Highers, I believe A-Levels are in between. His Highers are probably enough to get him into Uni or whatever

mcmuffin22 · 12/11/2026 17:22

Ibwould also not let him leave school until he applies to and gets into the forces. He could fail the medical and then have absolutely nothing to fall back on. It will also be quite a shock going from working in a cafe at weekends to joining the armed forces. He needs a decent plan in place to transition to this.

LiberteLynx · 12/11/2026 17:23

Newname26 · 12/11/2026 17:14

Advanced Highers is a one year course.

Scotland has Highers & Advanced Highers, I believe A-Levels are in between. His Highers are probably enough to get him into Uni or whatever

Ty, I am more used to the A level req to be an officer in the RAF. So Highers are below A levels? Then sometime in next two years he would need to complete the equivalent of 2 A levels. I hear you on adv highers being a 1 yr course. I think its too late to start them now for 2027 exams?

LiberteLynx · 12/11/2026 17:26

wildnwilde · 12/11/2026 17:13

Depends what you want to do. The army offers so many opportunities for further education and skills . No formal education isn’t the end of the world . Obviously if he has his heart set on certain roles some form of results may be required but it’s certainly not essential .

Yes it depends. I just hate to see him wasting time. Finishing at least to A level equivalent really helps if he has a goal of being an officer so he may regret wasting this academic year later down the road. But then again, some people need to make their own mistakes.

Lomonald · 12/11/2026 17:27

If he isn't going to sit his prelims and definitely not his Highers, i would say he is welcome to leave but he has to up his hours at work,even another day or two, then see how he gets on, but imo he can't fanny about for a year while you fund him.

Lomonald · 12/11/2026 17:30

If he leaves now and he is "refusing " to get more hours. Then give him a few months off then he has to do something.

monymonymony · 12/11/2026 17:37

I'd be tempted to threaten to kick him out if he doesn't put in his application for the forces. The reality is that there's very little for him to do at home, and he'll likely end up playing video games all night, sleeping during the day and getting his head filled with nonsense online.

Without money, structure or an occupation, he'll become increasingly isolated and risk wasting some of the best years of his life. When your youth and good health are the biggest advantages you have, the worst thing you can do is spend years sitting around your parents' house doing nothing instead of taking the opportunity to build a future for yourself.

Teawithfrenchtoast · 12/11/2026 17:39

@monymonymony agreed. We have been trying to get this across to him.

OP posts:
Bitsostuff · 12/11/2026 17:40

School or not school would be their choice but, in our family, we've always made it very clear that its full time education or full time work (and that we'd provide unpaid work to make up the hours if necessary). No freeloading off mummy and daddy.

In your shoes Id tell him how much you'd be charging him for rent and bills, make it clear he'd be paying his own phone contract, buying his own clothes as well as taking on am equal share of household work. Then let him choose.

wildnwilde · 12/11/2026 17:40

LiberteLynx · 12/11/2026 17:26

Yes it depends. I just hate to see him wasting time. Finishing at least to A level equivalent really helps if he has a goal of being an officer so he may regret wasting this academic year later down the road. But then again, some people need to make their own mistakes.

If he’s not engaged right now he’s kind of flogging a dead horse as he’s skipping classes not trying etc so in all likelihood is wasting time he could be utilising getting himself in a position to do a level when he’s more mature and has some sort of career . He will have the opportunity to take a levels at a later date . It’s pointless keeping in a place where he is not going to achieve a levels right now . I’m in a similar position with mine only it’s GCSEs . To leave him in school was to keep him on a downward spiral . I’m sure in a few years he will regret not taking advantage of school but my job now is to put him in the best position to achieve something to work with in the future . I think op might be in a similar situation with her lad . Sometimes time has to be wasted in the lomg run . Teenage boys do not think of the future the same way we do .

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/11/2026 17:40

Teawithfrenchtoast · 12/11/2026 16:50

@Newname26 Yes he did. He has Nat 5’s and Highers but no interest in continuing with his advanced higher courses. He doesn’t want to go to college or uni - he says he’s fed up of being in education.

I remeber very well that feeling of being done with education half way through 6th year - the deal was I could only if I had a full time job. Absolutely no chance of taking a year out for shits and giggles.

In saying that, jobs were easier to find - I went into an entry level job that taught me so much about turning up and working hard to progress. I did go back to education later, when I knew what I wanted to do. It was harder than going straight from school, because I was working and studying full time - but it worked for me.

Would he put together a plan - eg how he’s going to fund a year off, what he plans to do (volunteering, train for his services physical, learn a new skill), when he’s going to apply for the services, what he’s going to do to strengthen his application? He has some highers, so uni or training is an option if military service doesn’t work out.

WhereYouLeftIt · 12/11/2026 18:17

"We have told him that we’ll agree to him leaving school if he has a mid week job, is in further education or has his application in for which ever force he wishes to join - he feels we are being unreasonable and are preventing him from being his own person and living his own life."
He's operating under the illusion that it's only his decisions that matter. He really needs to take on board that the forces might decide they don't want someone with his attitude and lack of work ethic.

Newname26 · 12/11/2026 18:30

LiberteLynx · 12/11/2026 17:23

Ty, I am more used to the A level req to be an officer in the RAF. So Highers are below A levels? Then sometime in next two years he would need to complete the equivalent of 2 A levels. I hear you on adv highers being a 1 yr course. I think its too late to start them now for 2027 exams?

I don't know about getting into miliary but university if they want 2 A-levels the equivalent would be something like 3 Highers. Its not unusual for people to sit 4.

Not everyone does Advanced Highers and few people actually need them.
That might be part of the issue. He might already have the qualifications he needs for military.
A lots of people end up with uni offers based on Highers at the end of S5 but do S6 only because they are still only 16, and a bit young to be at uni, even more so now pubs are strict on seeing ID and Unis make it very clear if kids are under 18.

The boy is in S6 and doing Advanced Highers prelims (mocks) are in January but hes not been putting the effort in. School may discourage him from going for the actual exams in May.

gardenflowergirl · 13/11/2026 18:21

Living his own life and being his own person needs money, a job. Anyone that does a gap year saves up for it.

exaltedwombat · 13/11/2026 18:28

Why not let him try? It won’t make any difference to you, expense-wise if he lays around at home rather than laying around at school. If he gets bored, he’ll find something to do. Or not. Unless you’re seriously worried that he will turn to crime, just let go and see what happens.

AlexandraCarrington · 13/11/2026 18:40

It won’t make any difference to you, expense-wise if he lays around at home rather than laying around at school.

Won't Child Benefit cease if he's not in education?

RampantIvy · 13/11/2026 18:42

Teawithfrenchtoast · 12/11/2026 16:54

There is an access to uniformed services course at college however the next course will run from August next year.

we have suggested the cadets but they meet in the evenings.

What's the issue with cadets being in the evenings?

isthatblues · 13/11/2026 18:47

Is he a gamer? Is that what he’s wanting to do in his gap year? If so, be very careful.

He’ll lose fitness and possibly the ability to cope with the armed forces and everything that’s involved in basic training.