Please or to access all these features

Teenagers

Parenting teenagers has its ups and downs. Get advice from Mumsnetters here.

Academic mum, self employed dad, DS (14) stuck in the middle

30 replies

SecretsAndLies77 · 13/10/2026 18:18

Ok, so, maybe my title oversimplifies it a bit, so I'll try to explain. Please forgive the length.

Split up with x-DH almost 10 years ago. Have DD(16) who's super academic, and DS(14) who's equally bright but has completely different interests. He's doing absolutely fine in school for the moment - not the top, but a comfortably upper middle. Well behaved, loving, good boy, and very athletic which is relevant.

The problem is the future. x-DH works for himself and has become - if I'm being honest, through a huge stroke of luck - very successful (too long to explain what I mean by this, but he's not the role model he thinks he is, as he's not honest about his 'success story', which I know fully and our DC don't). Over the last year I've learnt that he is constantly telling both DC that, basically, people with jobs are stupid. And all sorts of American business-self-help inspired stuff which isn't always wrong, but he totally lacks nuance and context, and also sometimes is just blatantly disrespectful to anyone who's chosen a different track in life. My DC, particularly DS, are too young to apply any kind of critical thinking to what he tells them - they take it at face value and it's starting to cause me huge concern.

I'm a professional with a very high level of education and, while I earn about a fifth of what x-DH earns, my work is fulfilling, well respected and I contribute to society in various ways - in other words, there is a purpose to what I do beyond just the ££. I'm only saying this to back up my claim that people with jobs are not all just idiots who don't know what's good for them.....

DD doesn't care about what her dad says and isn't interested to work for herself. She'll go to uni and have a career of some kind.

DS, however, isn't keen on school at all, and keeps telling me that the second he's not obliged to go to school by law, he's going to leave and pursue his [insert here fun but expensive and dangerous extreme-sport type hobby] full time, so he can become a professional. Has stated clearly he'd rather die than work in an office environment and will never have a boss, because dad says that's a very bad idea.

I am worried that my son will leave school after GCSEs. This is absolutely not a dig at anyone who has that level of education, I'm not coming from a place of snobbery. It's just that, with about 50% of young people now having degrees, do you really want to sit in the bottom half of the population, education wise? In an ultra competitive job market (I mean general jobs, not his hobby)? When I've tried to say things like 'education keeps your options open' or 'don't put all your eggs into one basket (the hobby)' my DS gets very emotional and says that I don't believe in him (that he can make it in the ultra competitive sport).

I always said I'd never tell my kids what to do and would support them in whatever their ambition is. Is this now an example of exactly that situation, which I just can't recognise? Or is this something else, as what he's looking to do is incredibly hard to achieve and also seriously dangerous (an injury could take you out of the sport for good).

Even just the concept of working for yourself - yes, that's great, but surely you need some good knowledge and education under your belt to make a success of it? The most successful enterpreneurs are often very educated. The person who succeeds with zero GCSE is an exception, surely, and people with no qualifications typically end up with less choice over jobs open to them.

Am I wrong about all this? I'm struggling to separate reality from ideology/belief systems.

Do I just sit tight and hope this is a phase at 14 which will change by 18? Or do I keep trying to discuss it with him? Thank you in advance for your comments.

OP posts:
Walkingthroughautumn · 15/10/2026 07:42

Can you arrange for DS to have some other role models around? I realised recently that a lovely side effect of paying for a maths tutor for my son is that he has this brilliant extra male role model in his life who loves learning and is a good counterweight to his dad's mockery of him for working hard.

That said. I don't think either of you are right or wrong. I often find myself wondering whether I want my children to go to university, I think they would have to really want to go for me to think it a good idea.

And two of my family members made really good careers out of an extreme sport they love. For one it has been a career that has endured and paid very well, for the other it lasted him through most of his 20s then he shifted into a second (very well paid) career and negotiated to still have flexibility to accommodate his extreme sport hobby.

socialbatteryisdead · 15/10/2026 07:44

University is not necessary or achievable for everyone.
You can also attend university at any age.

Walkingthroughautumn · 15/10/2026 07:45

Pumpkindoodles · 14/10/2026 08:09

Can you be seen to be encouraging? But try to still push some education. So for example start talking about what would help him. Would a media, public relations type a level help him market himself - that’s very important for athletes these days for sponsorship. Would a business a level help him run his own business for example. Talk about making a plan for how he’s going to succeed at his dream, in the same way you’d make a plan if he were going to uni - how will he pay for things (job/student finance etc) where he’s going to live, what he’s going to do, how long it’s going to take and the steps to get there. Not in a gotcha told you this was a stupid idea way, but just start laying some foundations. He’s young so you don’t need to go into detail now, but just keep comparing it to going to uni, like this is his plan so you’re taking it seriously how it’s going to look.
he might realise it’s not going to work, or maybe you’ll equip him to have a better chance of success if he’s going to do it anyway.
tbh I’d also, not in a rude way, talk about the lots of luck that goes into anyone being successful, for example your dad had loads of help with x y z. He’s worked very hard as well, but it’s not all in our own hands…type thing

Yes this is good advice too. DD has always been clear she wants a particular career in the arts. So I regularly explain why being able to write clearly and have strong maths and business and IT skills will all be important.

I also try and emphasise the value of learning for the pure enjoyment of learning rather than for any particular end goal, and to model a love of lifelong learning

Shinyandnew1 · 15/10/2026 10:02

I would tell the children the truth behind the dad’s success. ‘Yes, he is successful now, but you won’t have the inheritance (or whatever it is that you know but they don’t) that helped him

Seagulldancing · 15/10/2026 10:08

Your DS is 14. He'll change his mind 100 times between now and being an independent adult. And he can make up his education if he leaves at 16, its not easy but loads do it. What you can't do is force a large hairy 16 year old into education they've decided they hate, it won't work and you'll resent each other.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread