M&S long sleeve boyfriend cardigan - Thoughts?

[OhCobblers]

Oh stylish lades please could i have your opintions on this M&S long sleeve boyfriend cardigan Black or khaki?

TIA

the black looks a bit see through

Surely that's only a boyfriend cardigan if your boyfriend is literally a giant??

I prefer the khaki - black probably a bit heavy and overpowering?

What material is it? I suspect it would lose its shape and 'seat' quite badly.

hmm, I bought a miles nicer one in Wallis recently, looks more expensive. That looks a bit thin to me. Plus I think proportions are wrong, its too long and too big around the hips

too long
but that is the essence of it isnt it

but theres long and theres long and shapeless