Bobbi Brown gel eyeliner or Badgal liner?

[laughterlines]

I have both which were given as presents although both are unopened and unused. I was thinking about ebaying one of them as could do with some spare cash at the moment but not sure which one.

I have read about Bobbi Brown gel liners drying up quickly. I have a duo pack of brown and black.

I don't mind a gel or a kohl liner, just after some opinions.

I've got both of these.

Bobbi Brown gel is good for more precise lines. Stays put all day, really nice, but a faff with the little brush etc.

Bad gal liner better for smoky eyes, goes on really well. It's the one I use most, tbh.

ah that is interesting BW
i like the gel one but its not aneveryday one for me as its quite defined.

my fave is eliz arden doublewear

Bad Gal eyeliner much better than Bad Gal mascara, which flakes off something wicked.

Thanks for your replies although it's really not helping as now I think I will have to keep both

Do you find the gel dries out quickly?

Not so far.

no