Can you check these for me before I order please?

[GossipMonger]

Are they frumpy?

these

and

these

Will ask DH for his opinion when he gets home from work but I was just wondering if I had become old lady wearing Clarks shoes??

I am 38 nearly 39.

TIA

I think they are quite frumpy tbh, but I do spend my life in ridiculous shoes.

I think they are quite cool
wiould definitely depend what you wear them with

Twinkle - do you think they are both frumpy because they are from Clarks?

If they had been from somewhere cooler do you think you might have liked them?

Thanks Trinity.

Am a TA at school, have 2 young boys, dont dress up a lot and wanted to have something to wear with trousers/jeans.....

??

i like the boots but not the shoes

agree it would depend what you wear them with

i am older than you but do try not to be frumpy

Have ordered the boots now along with a pair of white trainery things!

DH said the grey shoes were frumpy!

Tis an odd age to be late thirties/early forties methinks!!

Thanks

I am 46 and like the boots but not the shoes

I like the shoes but not the boots! LOL

i am 39. Like the boots, but not the shoes. They look like the kind of shoes that will make your feet look like the leave of a ficus tree.

I'm sorry but seeing you asked - I thing they are awful and frumy and would even make old people look older.

You are not yet 40 never mind 70. leave them alone!

Oh no! Too many opinions now and I have ordered the boots!

Will get them and see what they are like in RL.

Wonder if I dare post the dress that i want to order

...................

Oh Gossip...I do hope you get free returns with Clarkes!

yes,they are granny shoes

i don't like either.

like the shoes not the boots (too punky art student-y)

Sorry dont like either. Im 'old' and wouldnt wear either of these!

They're not Granny shoes unless you wear them with a long (Boden) skirt.

Skinny jeans and cropped hair and dangly earings should do it.. (Although you may end up looking like a social worker)

Oh dear. Sorry both are really awful.

Really terrible.

Age immaterial imo. My mother is 55 and wouldnt be caught dead in either.

Quite like the boots. I would wear them. Shoes are frumpy.

I decided that before I saw you'd ordered the boots. I'm 35.

I'm 31 and think they're ok. The boots could work with a funky skirt. But don't wear them with a long, mum-style skirt. The shoes are fine.

not mad on either here either im afraid!

they're not as old as a bolden tunic imo. if you are just schlepping around in jeans and those boots, i don't think it is making any massive statement. i think the boots i have on are from clarks!

I'm not keen on either

Gossip....Let us know if you liked them once they arrive!