SHIT my cardigan is sold out - help me choose between these two!

[Jewelsandgems]

cardigan 1

cardigan 2

I did originally want the boden cardigan dressing gown and was most annoyed to find out the sale had started, and it had gone (my DH annoyed too, because he was buying it for me)

So, plan b.....

step away from the boden

all saints one, easy. Boden is so blah

I agree foosa and louby but the boden one looks much warmer.....I do agree about the AS one being more stylish though

Boden = bollocks,

but not keen on the all saints either.

Nothing All Saints is machine wash, is it? But it is very nice.

OK elf, I am looking for a longer length carigan that I can mooch around in at home (and I have house guests next week so will need to be more covered up than usual at breakfast) and do not like big heavy towelling robes - have you seen anything nice?!! I do want it to look nice too, and be wearable outdoors.

I do like the black boden...

I don't think the All Saints one would be warm, though it is very nice. Do you need a cardigan to be warm though? If you do, then out of those two it would have to be Boden.

I think I saw a nice warm one in French Connection, will see if I can find it.

Toots it does say cotton, so I was kinda hoping it would be.....

Haven't found the one I was thinking of but here re some ideas -

Too chunky?

Super toasty warm

Too dressing gown-y?

I do like that third one norkily, nice grey colour too

Good.

Also grey

Similar to that Planet one but different colour

Love that second monsoon one norkily - thanks! I prefer that one to the boden one and because black is not a flattering colour for me.

Also discovered a rather nice one on jigsaw

here

LOVE this
OMG

They are lovely.

And pricey.

You could try Kew, they have really similar longline open cardis for cheaper? In lovely colours too.

I know norkily, especially that second jigsaw one - no way I'll be getting that.

I do like the kew ones and they do have lots of colours - like the dark teal. It hard without them being on a model/mannequin though so see the length/fit etc.

Thanks for all your help though, I now have quite a few to decide between!

The "long stitch" one is nice