Opinions on these boots pretty please

[BeauticianNotMagician]

Do you like any of these:
these
these
these
or these

Sorry im so poor right now and the ds's need so much that i need to get most of my autumn/winter wardrobe from the catalogue.I lost £500 on ebay so feeling poor right now and new boots will cheer me up

erm nooooooooooo sorry

No

i've realised i don't actually like knee length boots, i prefer them shorter.

first are ok

rest are not

m&S have noce ones this seasons for about 79

No.

But I hate cutoff square toes, and soles that can't be re-soled.

The top ones might be acceptable, but only if you already have flat feet/no arches.

I still haven't figured out how to do multiple links .

I like the top and third pair best

I liked them. Agree about the soles, and if I was picky I would so no because of teh soles, yes for the legs if that makes sense! The look comfy.

I like the first three particularly the Kickers ones. Not fussed on the last ones. Sadly my legs will never be long enough or thin enough to wear any of them!

Prefer the kickers ones. Do not like any of the others - sorry. Just think the others are lacking in style (although yes, they are 'functional'.)

Dont like any of them
esp the last ones - minging

i think the kickers are the best out of those

Thank you all.I like square toed best.I thought they were all ok just shows i have absolutely no fashion sense at all.In my defense i used to be three stone heavier and didnt care what i wore as nothing looked nice so this is all new to me.

Hi, I really like the Dune ones.Quite plain, and understated... Very nice, will go with anything.