Well, I can answer this now...
The Erinas is awful - v expensive even from M&M (80 odd down from 200ish?) and it's TOO LONG, the waist is kind of too low, the sleeves are extremely baggy and just weird shaped - it's loose round the middle, in short it's made for a 6ft person with very long, fat arms. So that's going back - nice and soft tho due to cashmere so a pity I got a 12 btw, am usually a 10 so get a 12 in coats, to go over stuff, but see below.
The Edger is also a weird shape - like those coats funeral directors wear. not good.
Also the 10 was extremely tight. Going back.
The Enola is still undecided. It's a lovely coat butthe shape is boxy and doesn't do much for the figure - however it is well made and fits well. That's another 12. Fur collar is quite nice too. I don't like the extra flappy bits on the back but they are Ok.
The Evangelista is the one I really liked in the picture.
It's not quite as nice as I hoped. VERY heavy and bulky, the fabric is 55 wool, 45 poly but feels like hardish cotton tbh. It picks up some fluff, but not dreadfully so.
It is a good length especially if tights or such, under - modest enough iyswim - and a nice shape. But it is bulky and you wouldn't want it on a warm autumn day. So very much a winter coat.
I think I'm going to keep it anyway as returns are not free, and sending back everything would be a shame! Plus it is probably going to be lovely when the weather is very cold.
There you go - hope it helps someone else decide! Website I used in the end was M&M direct so everything about 75% off.