Eyeliner that doesn't smudge and make me look like a panda?

[SuperBunny]

Is there such a thing? I usually use a grey-ish pencil and it looks fine when I leave the house but within an hour or two it ends up under my eyes too, leaving me with a rather attractive black-eye look.

What can I use that will look subtle but won't end up all over my face?

Bobbi Brown gel eyeliner. It really stays put.

Thanks! I've never tried gel eyeliner

Napoleon does eyeliner cake that you use a brush and waterproof liquid. It's an investment to start but liquid can be used with his eye shadow powders too. only thing that works on my greasy eyelids!

I swear by BeneFit Bad Gal eyeliner, expensive but lasts forever and really easy to apply.

Pencils always smudge on me. I ended up with some on my nose the other day. I find the body shop liquid one stays put quite well.

Best one I've ever found is Lancome.

i love benefit bad gal

there is a No 7 one which i tried and it didn't shift for 2 days

it is a new one and not sure of the name but it will not budge ....

Thanks all. Was hoping there would be suggestions for a cheapy one but looks like I lay have to splash out. I will have a look next weekend

I use a Rimmel liquid liner. Tis very cheap (can't remember exact price but, hey, its Rimmel so can't be too expensive!) and stays put beautifully.

Oo, rimmel. I can afford to try that this week! Thanks

Gel eyeliner is fab, looks really professional and lasts for ages. Takes a bit of time to get the knack though and is expensive if you have to get a brush etc. I like the L'oreal liquid eyeliner as well.