Boots glorious boots! which to keep, which to take back... you decide.

[MascaraOHara]

So today I bought GANG these in brown

and these

I want to wear them with skirts & thick tights as well as skinnt jeans etc.. which pair do you think I should keep??

2nd link didn't work - hang on

try this

the first ones!!!

first ones.

Keep the first pair. The 2nd pair look a little like they have those letterbox strip things on them, but the first are very nice.

Tough one. What's the price difference?

first ones too

First ones, they are lovely.

I prefer the second pair

def the 1st ones

first def

First - sorry, I don't like the 2nd unless you have yeti aspirations. The first look lovely and solid and would look great used to dress down a dress, with a long cardigan.

thew second ones look like there's a gremlin trying to escape. In a bad way.
The first ones are nice

there's about £30 price difference.. the 1st ones are cheaper and have a 'lighter' look iykwim but also look a bit cheap if I'm being honest.

The 2nd onces though look very heavy on.. and I'm wondering if they might look to heavy for skirts.

The 1st ones are winning margianlly as I think they are more versitile but I don't think they'll last long, sole feels very thin and they aren't real leather.

argh!

keep going guys because I'll end up going with the consensus.. I'm loving the both for entirely different reasons.

(Oh and the second pair I think will turn down nicely)

I knew I should have left them both in the shop lol

I like the first ones and quite fancy some myself but fear wd look muttony on me...(45)

1st ones.

The fluffy bits on the second ones will get dirty and they might not be so appropriate for autumn/spring - they look like winter only boots.

Would avoid them if not real leather tbh; especially if the weather plans to carry on like this!

The first ones are lovely although I have a pair of the second ones and they are sssooooo comfy. A bit too bulky for wearing with skirts but fab with jeans!

The second pair look really cozy!

I like both but prefer the first ones

Did you say they are not leather?

What about these

You can also get em in brown and they are sturdy leather

I kept the 1st ones and took the cat ones back.

wore them today - SO comfy!! and spent the 90-odd quid that the others would of cost on some funky tights, a jumpe dress, and a really cutsey floral print dress that I intend to wear them

quite pleased I couldn't find a holiday now