Duffle coats on adults. Good or bad?

[PeppermintPatty]

What do you think?

Or would you just look like an overgrown toddler??

I think okay on slightly fey indy looking blokes
not great on ladies unless very petite and have an elfin thing going on

agree slightly fey blokes; Brad Pitt would never get away with it

I am not elfin or petite, nor do I have short hair, although I am a bit indy. I have this duffle coat in sort of pastelly RAF blue (v much my colour). I love it and wear it with everything in the winter. my coat

I have one that I love from Gap last winter. Black with a bit of a swing shape to it at the back. So glad that this thread isn't a resounding no beause I love mine and don't want doubt to sour our relationship.

I've got that Top Shop one in red. I like it. But they have hiked the price up - was only £50 for the last 2 years.