Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Present for DS gilfriend (23), please help me choose

54 replies

sillyrubberduck · 20/11/2026 16:41

Looking for a present for DS’s girlfriend, 23, and have narrowed it down to a Monty Arc bag or a Neom Berry Blush diffuser.
She likes decorating her bedroom and does use handbags, but I’m really torn! I have attached the items I am considering.Also Monty bags come in different colours.
Which would you choose? Or neither? 😂 Would love some opinions, especially from younger Mumsnetters!
Thank you !!

Present for DS gilfriend (23), please help me choose
Present for DS gilfriend (23), please help me choose
OP posts:
Darklane · Yesterday 07:27

What about a scarf? Cashmere or lambswool depending on budget. It is winter & forecast to be a cold one. You probably have noticed what colours she likes.
I would not spend so much on a diffuser.

RumpelSpillskin · Yesterday 07:36

My 22y would not like those at all.

She would like a Dior lip oil, rhode stuff, Lego, jellycats, snoopy clothes, statement jewellery and gift cards from urban outfitters or Hollister.

Executrixnotextraordinaire · Yesterday 07:44

I have a late teen and an early twenties and I wouldnt buy either, a lot more suitable suggestions here, if you dont know her preferences Id go safe with a voucher, Sephora would be safe. Dior have some gorgeous gifts bought a really bling makeup bag with some quite neutral bits in for my younger DD, think it was just over £100 and you might get a deal on BF for somewhere.

RumpelSpillskin · Yesterday 07:48

My daughter also would like this

www.benefitcosmetics.com/en-gb/product/the-benemart-set-BENEMARTSET.html

timoteigirl · Yesterday 08:19

Does she use a handbag as not all women do? Take your clue from there. I would not buy a bag unless I know exactly what they want. If you don't her well can you ask your don what to get? Velvetiser she is likely yo already have if likes that sort of thing.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · Yesterday 09:52

Not keen on the bag and the diffuser is expensive - you could get something better for that amount. Perfume sounds a good bet or ask your son if there are any pieces of clothing she is wanting.

Chemenger · Yesterday 09:57

My 20 something DDs would not want that bag. It’s very distinctive and it would be a gamble to give it as a gift unless it had been asked for. I can’t imagine them being keen on the diffuser either to be honest. It’s something that usually gets suggested for someone’s mother.

Mary46 · Yesterday 11:44

I agree with bags.. my friend wears set colours. She might not like it. The lip oil a good suggestion.

professionalcommentreader · Yesterday 11:54

My 22 year old would like that diffuser, not the bag though.

hattie43 · Yesterday 11:56

I’d go Diffuser

luckylavender · Yesterday 12:04

Don’t buy the bag. Also a diffuser seems an older person’s present

jjw2002 · Yesterday 12:07

Dior lip oil, buy from Dior website and you get the name engraved on it and gorgeous packaging!
maybe also a compact mirror.

FroggyNo · Yesterday 12:10

Not keen on either idea.

Does she wear make up? Could get a lovely set from eg Dior- if you order from their website it comes in beautiful packaging and some things can be engraved.

Royaly82 · Yesterday 12:15

Its lovely you are going to so much effort 🙂
None of my 3 oldest daughters (26, 20 and 18) would like that bag and they all have quite different tastes.
The defuser is a nice idea but as someone else said above. You could not go wrong with a space NK voucher for the same price (im actually doing gift cards for all of them along with a lunch voucher so they can have a shopping day out together as their main present and space NK is one of them!

ExitPursuedByABare · Yesterday 12:16

My DD, 27, lives and works in London and requested a Monty bag for her birthday. She loves it and takes it work every day.

KatMansfield6 · Yesterday 12:17

The Monty bags are very fashionable with mid 20s at the moment! My sister has one and she is exactly that demographic.Probably a certain type of mid 20s (arty/"hipster" ). Definitely a different type of 20s yr old to those who wear lulumelon... A lot of the suggestions would not suit a more alternative person, so it depends what she's like. I have a neon diffuser and I love it -- it's not a certain scent, you add diffuser oils to it and there are some great ones (look up home scents etc). Not saying either of them would definitely work but just defending the ops options.

SandyThumb · Yesterday 12:19

Have bought the following for the DS's 22-24 yr old girlfriends over the last few years. All seem to have gone down well:

  • Theatre voucher (loves musicals)
  • Cinema gift card
  • Elizabeth Scarlett make up/ toiletry bags (likes nature/ animals)
  • Variety of things from Oliver Bonas
  • Bits and bobs of jewellry from https://wildspiritlondon.com/
  • Cookery books (loves cooking)
  • Edible stuff such as spice/ paste gift packs e.g. Belazu
  • Cute and warm scarf and socks combos - fat face etc

But I'm also running out of ideas!

Wild Spirit

Discover Wild Spirit London, where boho meets bling in our collection of uplifting natural stone jewellery. Embrace your wild side with our unique pieces designed to inspire and empower. Shop now to add some personality and style to an outfit.

https://wildspiritlondon.com

SandyThumb · Yesterday 12:21

And please don't buy the diffuser - I had a terrible asthma attack when I stayed in an Air BnB that had loads of them! We had to put them all outside the front door!

TerfOnATrain · Yesterday 12:23

Don't get a bag unless she specifically has mentioned one. DD used to say to me every Christmas when her MiL chose presents "What am I supposed to do with this monstrosity mum?" Her MiL doesn't have daughters and often got it wrong. These days she has defaulted to an M&S or John Lewis voucher after hints from DD. Always appreciated.

KatMansfield6 · Yesterday 12:25

But I think the op has her finger on the pulse of a certain type of mid 20s woman -- obviously not ALL mid 20s are going to like Monty bags. But a mid 20s woman who likes lulumelon and hollister is going to be pretty different to one who likes Monty...

Autumnishere1 · Yesterday 12:33

Bags are risky, it's a very personal choice, so unless she has mentioned she loves that particular brand and style, I would avoid buying that. I think you can do better than a diffuser as well to be honest. I don't have daughters, but when I was that age I wouldn't have wanted a diffuser, I would have preferred nice make up, perfumes etc.

ilovepixie · Yesterday 12:34

Neither!

chirrupybird · Yesterday 12:40

Something that gets used up, a bag is difficult she may not like it, the diffuser may not be much better will she like the scent? I would go for candles if you go in that direction like the big Yankee candles or a few different scents of smaller ones. Can you get any hints from your son about what she likes? Or go safe but boring and get say an M&S gift card so she can choose something.

Mightaswellsetamantrap · Yesterday 15:59

countrylifeorcitylife · 20/11/2026 22:38

100% the defuser!

In case of a Christmas explosive device.

sillyrubberduck · Yesterday 18:14

Thank you all for your comments . I think you are right, I have abandoned the bag and diffuser ideas.
I’m now thinking : Dior lip gloss gift set and/or turtle doves fingerless gloves . Maybe a spa voucher for two .

OP posts: