Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Help me with the never ending quest for the perfect work/commuter bag

55 replies

Oneandonex · 16/11/2026 09:15

I just can’t seem to get this right! Have a fairly long London commute, 30 mins of which are by foot so I need a bag that is comfortable.
I currently have a sandqvist nackpack (the biker type) which I love, however, is it quite narrow and I struggle to properly fit in a lunch bag for the days I bring food in (usually breakfast and lunch and I like using the lunch bag because I put a little ice pack to keep my yogurt fresh). In addition to that I just carry normal stuff like laptop, umbrella, glasses, a notebook, phone and keys etc.

I have had a knomo before but didn’t love it so had sold it and got the Sandqvist instead.
What I am looking for is essentially a bag that is:
Comfy and practical
Stylish too
Spacious enough for all of the above plus maybe a book without being huge

Budget is up to £150 but can stretch to £200 for the perfect solution.

Don’t like the very classic looking work backapacks like samsonite, targus etc. I find them a bit too masculine iykwim.

Can anyone help!?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
BlueberryMess · 16/11/2026 09:29

This may not be big enough but it is a fabulous bag. Really comfortable, lots of pockets and looks great

https://www.decathlon.co.uk/p/pu-backpack-with-laptop-pocket-commute-500-15l/360277/c394m8928088

Tortephant · 16/11/2026 09:36

Rains?

Smallbrowndog · 16/11/2026 10:26

You could try Kipling - I have one which would tick all your boxes except size, as I don't need to bring a lunch in.

They're well made, comfortable and light, and if you get the right colour, fairly smart.

Oneandonex · 16/11/2026 10:56

I don’t mind the look of roka but the straps seem a bit uncomfortable…

Has anyone tried Fjallraven? Not the Kanken, the slightly more sturdy ones?

OP posts:
Q2C4 · 16/11/2026 12:30

Oneandonex · 16/11/2026 10:56

I don’t mind the look of roka but the straps seem a bit uncomfortable…

Has anyone tried Fjallraven? Not the Kanken, the slightly more sturdy ones?

I’ve had a large Roka Bantry for years and I regularly overload it with iPad, note book, 2 sets of headphones, water bottle, chargers, snacks etc. It’s a very robust bag which has coped very well with this heavy loading and I have never found the straps uncomfortable.

I’m not on commission, honest!

myladyjane · 16/11/2026 13:46

Oh I have a Roka after a long search - I am short with a short torso and a lot of backpacks feel uncomfortable. Shoulder bags hurt my back so they are out.

it’s not the bantry I have, it’s a smaller, mid size one. I get laptop, make up bag, brolly and small lunch box in fine. Straps secure and comfortable.

i was not a fan pre purchase but it was on offer and i was desperate. Now my favourite work bag - not beautiful but light, practical and plain.

my friend loves her Kaptan which is nicer to look at and they often have offers too

Stowickthevast · 16/11/2026 17:10

I have a Roka and actually find the side pockets aren't really big enough to carry a water bottle when you have a laptop and lunch box in as well. They are but it's a mission to shove them in.

I have the Canfield large one.

I've been thinking of the Stubble & Co ones but they're a similar size.

NellietheNumpty · 16/11/2026 17:15

I have Roka. It can carry laptop, work headphone set, packed lunch and water bottle and is comfortable enough to cycle or carry 45 minutes to work. 4 years old and as good as new. I have washed it a few times.

ScratchedSkirtings · 16/11/2026 17:31

Oneandonex · 16/11/2026 10:56

I don’t mind the look of roka but the straps seem a bit uncomfortable…

Has anyone tried Fjallraven? Not the Kanken, the slightly more sturdy ones?

I have a smallish kanken- it does fit a laptop, notebook, brolly, lunch, snack and breakfast, but the book is usually too much of a squeeze and the side pocket only fits one particular tiny water bottle. I feel like I see bigger kankens on the tube though?? The straps are thin, but I’ve trudged around a fair amount with it fully laden and it’s fine - I’ve had it for 10 years now and showing no real signs of wear!

Oneandonex · 16/11/2026 18:28

I have a lunch bag that i use to carry my lunch which makes it harder as it’s obv bulkier than a simple lunch box. I use it to keep food fresher as i have a long commute.
What I dislike about the biker type (the ones that roll up at the top) is that I also find it difficult to get stuff in and out of it, like books for example.
I will look into some of the ones you recommended above!

OP posts:
Horsedatives · 16/11/2026 18:51

Longchamp? Do you mind shoulder carrry?

Iheartmysmart · 16/11/2026 19:06

I bought DS a Fjallraven for his birthday around nine years ago. It lasted him through college and Uni and has been on many, many holidays with him. It’s looking a little worse for wear now but has withstood an awful lot over the years. I can’t recall the exact model but it wasn’t a kanken - it has proper padded straps.

I ordered a Roka and sent it back as the straps were too uncomfortable. Some of the Pacsafe ones are nice. I have a small city pack and it’s very well made with the bonus of being theft proof.

Thingamebobwotsit · 16/11/2026 19:11

Deuter used to do women's proportion back packs. Best commute bag I ever had in terms of fit and comfort. Come in a range of colours and super comfortable even when stacked up for a long commute.

deuter SL backpacks
https://www.deuter.com/uk-en/backpacks/sl-backpacks-slim-line/

Traveltart · 16/11/2026 20:59

Tortephant · 16/11/2026 09:36

Rains?

I love the look of the Rains backpack but I had one and the zip broke just after it was out of warranty… So proceed with caution.

Vanillaicelatte · 16/11/2026 21:53

Mia Tui have some great bags
lorts of seperate compartments most have a water bottle compartment and other useful stuff

Clarinetiu · 16/11/2026 22:12

Nordace?

HRTea · 16/11/2026 22:13

The Maus one is amazing. My dad and husband both love theirs. The zip makes it incredibly easy to access, the fastening is adjustable, my husband massively overstuffs his and years later it’s still like new. They both get admiring comments about it all the time.

https://uk.mous.co/products/day-backpack-sage?variant=42556680962105

Sage Flap Backpack - Day

Perfect for everyday use, our Day Backpack combines an effortless, minimalist design with unmatched ease of access – simply unzip to access the entire bag in one go.

https://uk.mous.co/products/day-backpack-sage?variant=42556680962105

Sparklehorse47 · 16/11/2026 22:36

I have a Bellroy transit worker pack, the smaller one. Fits my laptop, lunch etc is very well made and waterproof. Also very comfortable. Very simple clean design, unisex so you might find it a bit masculine but I’m happy with it! They have tote bag style ones which are nice too

catspyjamas1 · 16/11/2026 22:48

Stubble and Co. UK owned. Best bag I've had in 20yr commute.

chalkyc2 · 16/11/2026 23:00

I have the rains Texel Tote - it’s everything you want in terms of size and comfort. I just don’t love the look of it though. It’s kind of fine, but so dull.

https://uk.rains.com/products/texel-tote-backpack?channable=4288f86964003530333035353931363430333034f0&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=22990329093&gbraid=0AAAAADDP_m-jjZwoL8eh3keljasyj48jP&gclid=Cj0KCQiA8OrXBhDEARIsAECtlx5PmTUkDJFJ6ip-hoCCnQm0_B5uot4ISU9qQSJJ4qKKveH8S2p8nlEaAqIZEALw_wcB&variant=50305591607536

I also feel like a great work bag is like the holy grail. I’ve tried the ever popular Roka and hated it. I have a couple of Ally Capellino backpacks - one is too small and the other too big.

I hate carrying my (big) laptop and lunch around but seems unavoidable - I look back at the early 2000s when I hardly carried anything but my keys, crappy phone and a paperback!

Rains® Texel Tote Backpack in Black for £139 | 2-Year Warranty

Buy Rains® Texel Tote Backpack in Black for £139. Wide selection of Backpack. Fast Delivery | 2-Year Warranty.

https://uk.rains.com/products/texel-tote-backpack?channable=4288f86964003530333035353931363430333034f0&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=22990329093&gbraid=0AAAAADDP_m-jjZwoL8eh3keljasyj48jP&gclid=Cj0KCQiA8OrXBhDEARIsAECtlx5PmTUkDJFJ6ip-hoCCnQm0_B5uot4ISU9qQSJJ4qKKveH8S2p8nlEaAqIZEALw_wcB&variant=50305591607536

EleanorMc67 · 17/11/2026 00:21

I realise that I'll be in the minority on this thread - but I don't think that a backpack/rucksack can ever be truly stylish ... sorry!

Practical & well-designed & functional, yes - but stylish, no ...

If I'm lugging things around for a while, I find a large cross-body bag best. Have a look at Anna Pugh's bags. The Hally is the most well-known, but there are a few others. They can be customised re strap length too.

https://annapugh.co.uk/collections/cross-body

Help me with the never ending quest for the perfect work/commuter bag
Help me with the never ending quest for the perfect work/commuter bag
Help me with the never ending quest for the perfect work/commuter bag
Help me with the never ending quest for the perfect work/commuter bag
Help me with the never ending quest for the perfect work/commuter bag
SpainToday · 17/11/2026 06:41

Another vote for Roka here.

But two great tips (which I got from this very page) firstly: take a tiny clutch or cross body bag, which fits into your rucksack, for things like phone, purse and keys, which you need to keep to hand. This is also useful if you nip out at lunch time, meaning you don’t need to take your back pack with you. Secondly, if you find the perfect bag, but don’t want to squash your lunch whilst packing, think about a carabina clip, and clip your lunch bag to your main bag.