Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Is this a boring dress?

122 replies

LemonSherbertsss · 15/11/2026 03:14

Hi all, first time posting so please be gentle. I would like to get opinions / inspo for my work Christmas party in December.

It’s a formal dress code but a relatively relaxed affair in a restaurant, cocktail party, canapés, fun awards sort of vibe.

I am late 30s, 5’5’’, size 8/10. Untoned tummy with caesarean pooch so I prefer a fit and flare or drop waisted cut - absolutely no bodycon!

I tried this on in River Island and felt the fit was perfect but the colour scheme (black top and champagne attached skirt) was maybe a bit ‘meh’. The material also felt quite cheap so I’m not sure how special it is.

ignore the gormless socks - will be wearing a heel on the actual night!

Any recommendations would be welcome. I’d rather spend no more than £100 but also open to renting a dress so if anyone suggests some more expensive options those are also welcomed as I’ll try and find it on a rental site.

Is this a boring dress?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
32
Nylonflares · 16/11/2026 22:09

Tiredhappymum · 16/11/2026 22:07

I was thinking that! They’re hideous! I can’t understand why they always get recommended on her.

Just the dresses of despair, awful

EleanorMc67 · 16/11/2026 22:20

NanofTwo · 16/11/2026 05:25

For a much older lady! Seriously Op is young and gorgeous

Being young & gorgeous means you can wear anything, does it not? It seems to get stated on here a lot! So she can wear it with a heavy dose of irony then ... though I don't think she'd need to ... Accessorised properly, I think she'd look great in it - it's perfect for her colouring.

PeppyRoseBeaker · 16/11/2026 23:16

Not nice

Anonanonay · Yesterday 00:42

Honestly I think that dress would make a supermodel look frumpy. It's awful.

EleanorMc67 · Yesterday 03:13

I do find it slightly odd, with regards to those who like the River Island dress/hate the Sister Jane ones, that no-one has picked up on the fact that the two are not that dissimilar in terms of their influences.

The River Island one is a very literal copy of so many 1980s dresses - boned velvet top, full taffeta bottom - but executed very cheaply (which the OP noticed herself). Even basic high-street versions of this dress in the 1980s would have been hugely better in terms of quality - so if I were the OP, & liked the style but not the quality, I'd look for an original version.

Sister Jane is known for its retro-inspired styles (drawing from the 1930s-80s, I would say), & the dresses posted are mostly 80s-influenced (a couple are more 60s) - just like the River Island one, although not as directly copied. In fact, they're not dissimilar in shape to some 80s Laura Ashley dresses.

What they have in common is a playfulness about them in terms of proportion & volume - they're meant to be (girls just wanna have!) fun, rather than slinky/bodycon/bombshell in style or seductive in intention.

I suppose I'm coming from the angle of fashion history, as I've always loved vintage clothing & find it interesting to see how current fashion trends alway plunder the past to a degree. So the similarity of influence is quite obvious to me & I think a couple of the Sister Jane dresses have a similar spirit to the River Island one - just a lot more vibrant!!

EleanorMc67 · Yesterday 03:26

The River Island dress - alongside some original 80s dresses with black velvet tops, & contrasting silk/taffeta/satin skirts. To me, the influence is very obvious.

Is this a boring dress?
Is this a boring dress?
Is this a boring dress?
Is this a boring dress?
Is this a boring dress?
EleanorMc67 · Yesterday 03:31

And a couple of 80s-influenced Sister Jane dress, alongside similar puff-sleeved, full-skirted original 80s dresses. Dresses of despair, apparently ...!!!

Is this a boring dress?
Is this a boring dress?
Is this a boring dress?
Is this a boring dress?
Is this a boring dress?
OrangeBlossomsinthesun · Yesterday 07:30

EleanorMc67 · Yesterday 03:13

I do find it slightly odd, with regards to those who like the River Island dress/hate the Sister Jane ones, that no-one has picked up on the fact that the two are not that dissimilar in terms of their influences.

The River Island one is a very literal copy of so many 1980s dresses - boned velvet top, full taffeta bottom - but executed very cheaply (which the OP noticed herself). Even basic high-street versions of this dress in the 1980s would have been hugely better in terms of quality - so if I were the OP, & liked the style but not the quality, I'd look for an original version.

Sister Jane is known for its retro-inspired styles (drawing from the 1930s-80s, I would say), & the dresses posted are mostly 80s-influenced (a couple are more 60s) - just like the River Island one, although not as directly copied. In fact, they're not dissimilar in shape to some 80s Laura Ashley dresses.

What they have in common is a playfulness about them in terms of proportion & volume - they're meant to be (girls just wanna have!) fun, rather than slinky/bodycon/bombshell in style or seductive in intention.

I suppose I'm coming from the angle of fashion history, as I've always loved vintage clothing & find it interesting to see how current fashion trends alway plunder the past to a degree. So the similarity of influence is quite obvious to me & I think a couple of the Sister Jane dresses have a similar spirit to the River Island one - just a lot more vibrant!!

I think both the river island dress and the sister Jane ones are unattractive.

Divebar2021 · Yesterday 10:26

OrangeBlossomsinthesun · Yesterday 07:30

I think both the river island dress and the sister Jane ones are unattractive.

Edited

Well you’re not asking the question are you. The OP chose a short flirty dress and the Sister Jane link also had dresses in the same spirit. They were a bit more indulgent for a formal outfit occasion and were in many cases within budget ( that many posters chose to ignore ). I wouldn’t wear a puff sleeve through choice but I recognise that Sister Jane is a current, popular brand.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 12:06

I don't think it's boring but the proportions and length are wrong for a sticky out skirt.

I think a pencil style in that length would suit you, or A-Line that is either shorter or below knee.

With your legs and figure a mini dress would look great, here is one in a champagne colour.

https://www.newlook.com/uk/womens/clothing/dresses/apricot-stone-sequin-lines-a-line-mini-dress/p/948018116

Or if you want to stick with the two tone theme of the original dress, perhaps reversed and slightly longer would work.

https://www.roman.co.uk/sequin-bodice-belted-chiffon-dress-14584633

Here is a more fitted dress in the colour scheme.

https://www.sosandar.com/black-gold-foil-print-pencil-dress

Apricot Stone Sequin Lines A-Line Mini Dress | New Look

Shop Apricot Stone Sequin Lines A-Line Mini Dress. Discover the latest trends at New Look.

https://www.newlook.com/uk/womens/clothing/dresses/apricot-stone-sequin-lines-a-line-mini-dress/p/948018116

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 12:10

EleanorMc67 · Yesterday 03:26

The River Island dress - alongside some original 80s dresses with black velvet tops, & contrasting silk/taffeta/satin skirts. To me, the influence is very obvious.

I had a dress like the second dark gold longer skirted one in about 1989/90, my first slightly more grown up formal dress. Velvet top, viscose skirt, was from Next. I was 14/15 and I felt very sophisticated in it.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 12:18

For the 1980s puffball style, not a very good photo, but I love this one worn by the character Kay Walters in The Newsreader.

eBay is your friend from something like that.

https://www.ebay.com/b/Bubble-Black-1980s-Vintage-Dresses-for-Women/175784/bn_111692869

Is this a boring dress?
DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 12:27

Here is a better photo.

Is this a boring dress?
MFL · Yesterday 12:28

My DD has a black fitted velvet dress with a silk puffball skirt. It’s short though. These aren’t cheap dresses if you want boning and decent fabrics. They weren’t cheap in the 80s either. The key is to have it all black and shorter. The cream skirt and just above the knee length are all wrong. Lots of stores have them in for parties right now.

dollyblue01 · Yesterday 12:30

Have a look on asos , you can add accessories to see a look that you’re trying to get, or to see what works and what doesn’t. You have a great figure don’t let your tummy stop
you, hold in knickers are your friend , especially when wearing dresses.

OrangeBlossomsinthesun · Yesterday 15:04

Divebar2021 · Yesterday 10:26

Well you’re not asking the question are you. The OP chose a short flirty dress and the Sister Jane link also had dresses in the same spirit. They were a bit more indulgent for a formal outfit occasion and were in many cases within budget ( that many posters chose to ignore ). I wouldn’t wear a puff sleeve through choice but I recognise that Sister Jane is a current, popular brand.

Yeah, sure but in terms of this "What they have in common is a playfulness about them in terms of proportion & volume - they're meant to be (girls just wanna have!) fun, rather than slinky/bodycon/bombshell in style or seductive in intention." I mean, what I meant was they´re just both ugly however you dress it up, excuse the pun.

EleanorMc67 · Yesterday 15:50

OrangeBlossomsinthesun · Yesterday 07:30

I think both the river island dress and the sister Jane ones are unattractive.

Edited

At least you're being consistent!

Fine, they're styles you don't like. I wouldn't wear any of them either (though I'd probably wear some less exaggerated bits from SJ). But I prefer a couple of the SJ ones to some of the more conventional black glittery offerings, as I think they look a bit cheap & boring.

I don't understand someone hating the SJ ones & not the RI one though - as they plunder from the same fashion period.

EleanorMc67 · Yesterday 16:07

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 12:10

I had a dress like the second dark gold longer skirted one in about 1989/90, my first slightly more grown up formal dress. Velvet top, viscose skirt, was from Next. I was 14/15 and I felt very sophisticated in it.

I was much more indie/alternative - a bit Gothy - back then, & really disliked all those sorts of dresses as they were the conventional "nice girl" dresses back then!!

When I started uni & went to my first ball, I fancied myself as a bit of a rebel in my ripped vintage tulle ballgown that I'd beaded myself, & DMs with customised velvet ribbon laces, & crimped hair & eyeliner ... In reality though, I'd just left a Convent grammar school, if that excuses me from sounding up myself (the truth is though is that I was terribly shy & insecure!).

And even more ironically, now I really love seeing the influence of those types of dresses (& that of other 80s/90s styles) on today's fashions. And how they get reinterpreted by subsequent generations, like my goddaughter.

EleanorMc67 · Yesterday 16:11

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 12:18

For the 1980s puffball style, not a very good photo, but I love this one worn by the character Kay Walters in The Newsreader.

eBay is your friend from something like that.

https://www.ebay.com/b/Bubble-Black-1980s-Vintage-Dresses-for-Women/175784/bn_111692869

All those images I posted are from eBay & Etsy. There are absolutely loads of them - some overpriced, some going for an absolute song. Lots are real silk & cotton velvet etc, & will be vastly better quality than the RI one (& probably the SJ ones in terms of natural fabrics).

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 21:32

EleanorMc67 · Yesterday 16:07

I was much more indie/alternative - a bit Gothy - back then, & really disliked all those sorts of dresses as they were the conventional "nice girl" dresses back then!!

When I started uni & went to my first ball, I fancied myself as a bit of a rebel in my ripped vintage tulle ballgown that I'd beaded myself, & DMs with customised velvet ribbon laces, & crimped hair & eyeliner ... In reality though, I'd just left a Convent grammar school, if that excuses me from sounding up myself (the truth is though is that I was terribly shy & insecure!).

And even more ironically, now I really love seeing the influence of those types of dresses (& that of other 80s/90s styles) on today's fashions. And how they get reinterpreted by subsequent generations, like my goddaughter.

I was never a goth, other than wearing heavy eyeliner and dyeing my hair a shade darker as a nod to it, but I tan too easily!

Had a go a grunge but I liked being clean. Don't think I found my feet with fashions until the mid 90s. Little skirts, fitted tops and coloured trainers were much more my thing.

EleanorMc67 · Yesterday 22:47

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 21:32

I was never a goth, other than wearing heavy eyeliner and dyeing my hair a shade darker as a nod to it, but I tan too easily!

Had a go a grunge but I liked being clean. Don't think I found my feet with fashions until the mid 90s. Little skirts, fitted tops and coloured trainers were much more my thing.

I was only really Goth-lite ... Loved black - but also loved colour too much!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page