Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Yellow coat - yes or no?

90 replies

CoveredInCheese · 14/11/2026 09:31

I’m looking for a new coat, and I really like bright shades - I’d rather freeze than buy something in navy or grey! I’ve seen this on the Debenhams website, which I think is really unusual and lovely:

Dream coat

However, I made the mistake of showing it to DP and he said over his dead body. He said he refuses to go out with Ruth Madoc and that, if I buy it, he will either hide it or “accidentally” spill red wine down it.

Who is right? And is it wrong that I’m already mentally listing items of his I could burn in retaliation?

Yellow Star by Julien Macdonald Button Through Coat | Debenhams

Discover Button Through Coat available to buy online at debenhams.com. Available with quick delivery and easy return options. Shop now!

https://www.debenhams.com/product/star-by-julien-macdonald-button-through-coat_p-c49d6535-7811-4f51-b71d-3ffd7a9901a3?colour=Yellow

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
EleanorMc67 · 15/11/2026 19:22

And this Jaeger one in mustard wool, in size 12. This & the Desigual one are proper winter jackets/short coats. The Julien Macdonald one isn't (though I have never been a fan of his clothing or his own personal ... "style"!!).

https://ebay.io/m/vkswGd

Yellow coat - yes or no?
HoraceCope · 15/11/2026 19:24

it doesnt look appropriate for the current weather in the uk

EleanorMc67 · 15/11/2026 19:39

Wool-mix 14 - https://ebay.io/m/5cHCrq

Yellow coat - yes or no?
EleanorMc67 · 15/11/2026 19:43

If you don't like the thought of eBay etc, the Desigual wool one is in several sizes here. In yellow or blue.

https://www.belledivino.co.uk/products/desigual-shortcolour-smart-boucle-coat-yellow-blue-25wwew11?currency=GBP&country=GB&variant=56945956487549&utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=Google+Shopping&stkn=a843f602d7a8&srsltid=AYCX9vKU085AfEzrBGzKFBbiQcOZlyC7lTvD7IcDoK0M4JSQqGJYd79S3pY&_su_rec=mx2PRU9TZj65kHgRGOhgiE-ZKescHUybBopiMvxE-0XoKSouRQA8pZ09uPTJp9k2Dj0CD14hX-ky6XIYlNOc9qaQ7bmWKTc0xz3VNRdWmrx4Tbznmho4MgJjvfWM0TYOwaQobVZifmCjYK3xLkmYhxuwzq1FyXOUuuW0SVjQYHjbU66pazXKIRABgiFMPJF2yECk8eFxMVb6f4gUwLcrDZFAykeB0X7bHZU-WmuYowaEKhWuCR4XEeSv0SqsNYmJgXlFEluwe72ZHybwFPwXH7BdW_2yBvjK206gejVuxwOpXWoENns_Wd9ecm6BHqPehX2VQlSLwKJdfOCW_mCtnYs13JDcf3d7Ljo_bUWVElL5ZbN57z_sKYpyuDDQ2U0BT5jT-SU9RxqWYbdZOUIsxY-fP-gKy3tSfYAsKfo46VA0P2MTzWnz9g&_su_rec_id=97f74da0-1112-4aa0-943d-7dd35645ac26-1794771716

Desigual Shortcolour Smart Boucle Coat Yellow / Blue 25WWEW11

Short boucle coat with lapel collar, double-breasted front, and solid color pockets. Color: Solid Fit: Regular Sleeve: Long Length: Short Front pockets Closure: Button Recycled polyester Model’s measurements: Height: 179 cm Model size: M SKU: 25WWEW118...

https://www.belledivino.co.uk/products/desigual-shortcolour-smart-boucle-coat-yellow-blue-25wwew11?_su_rec=mx2PRU9TZj65kHgRGOhgiE-ZKescHUybBopiMvxE-0XoKSouRQA8pZ09uPTJp9k2Dj0CD14hX-ky6XIYlNOc9qaQ7bmWKTc0xz3VNRdWmrx4Tbznmho4MgJjvfWM0TYOwaQobVZifmCjYK3xLkmYhxuwzq1FyXOUuuW0SVjQYHjbU66pazXKIRABgiFMPJF2yECk8eFxMVb6f4gUwLcrDZFAykeB0X7bHZU-WmuYowaEKhWuCR4XEeSv0SqsNYmJgXlFEluwe72ZHybwFPwXH7BdW_2yBvjK206gejVuxwOpXWoENns_Wd9ecm6BHqPehX2VQlSLwKJdfOCW_mCtnYs13JDcf3d7Ljo_bUWVElL5ZbN57z_sKYpyuDDQ2U0BT5jT-SU9RxqWYbdZOUIsxY-fP-gKy3tSfYAsKfo46VA0P2MTzWnz9g&_su_rec_id=97f74da0-1112-4aa0-943d-7dd35645ac26-1794771716&country=GB&currency=GBP&srsltid=AYCX9vKU085AfEzrBGzKFBbiQcOZlyC7lTvD7IcDoK0M4JSQqGJYd79S3pY&stkn=a843f602d7a8&variant=56945956487549

AnnaQuayRules · 15/11/2026 19:48

I have a woollen coat in a mustard colour which I love. But it's a long coat and the colour is more muted.

Sorry OP, but that jacket is not a nice colour and is very dated.

Pinkissmart · 15/11/2026 20:22

Buy it if you love it.
In a few months we’ll be counting the minutes of sunshine we’ve had all winter.
If it makes you happy, get it

FindingMeno · 16/11/2026 17:36

EleanorMc67 · 15/11/2026 19:22

And this Jaeger one in mustard wool, in size 12. This & the Desigual one are proper winter jackets/short coats. The Julien Macdonald one isn't (though I have never been a fan of his clothing or his own personal ... "style"!!).

https://ebay.io/m/vkswGd

God that is awful.
I think I'd change my name to Ethel and get a tartan trolley bag with a built in seat to style that one 😬
Sorry!!!

OsfameronTanamoril · 16/11/2026 17:47

EleanorMc67 · 15/11/2026 19:22

And this Jaeger one in mustard wool, in size 12. This & the Desigual one are proper winter jackets/short coats. The Julien Macdonald one isn't (though I have never been a fan of his clothing or his own personal ... "style"!!).

https://ebay.io/m/vkswGd

I like this. Mustard rather than shrieking yellow. I am dark skinned. Wear mustard and rust orange a lot. But deeper rather than bright.

EleanorMc67 · 16/11/2026 19:46

FindingMeno · 16/11/2026 17:36

God that is awful.
I think I'd change my name to Ethel and get a tartan trolley bag with a built in seat to style that one 😬
Sorry!!!

Bear in mind that it's the OP's taste, not mine, that's drawn towards bright yellow peacoats ...

I'm just trying to provide some slightly better options that are wool not synthetic, secondhand not new, & therefore better in sustainability terms than the one she's thinking of buying!! (And better for most people's retinas too ...!!)

MsMacheath · 16/11/2026 20:04

EleanorMc67 · 15/11/2026 19:45

It does illustrate how dreadful that colour is on a pinkish-skinned blonde, though

Eh? I don't see anything wrong with it.

EleanorMc67 · 16/11/2026 20:15

MsMacheath · 16/11/2026 20:04

It does illustrate how dreadful that colour is on a pinkish-skinned blonde, though

Eh? I don't see anything wrong with it.

No? It was the first thing I noticed. Such a bright, strong yellow is IMO not an easy colour to wear successfully.

It's such an intense colour that it makes her ashy blonde hair look really dull. It's most obvious in the picture from the rear, where there are no distractions from other colours. And her pink-toned colouring jars with it - as does her make-up. It would look a bit better if she was wearing a lipstick of a similar intensity, in a warm colour like rust or burgundy. But it still doesn't suit her.

However, I think we see colour differently!!!

MsMacheath · Yesterday 12:18

EleanorMc67 · 16/11/2026 20:15

No? It was the first thing I noticed. Such a bright, strong yellow is IMO not an easy colour to wear successfully.

It's such an intense colour that it makes her ashy blonde hair look really dull. It's most obvious in the picture from the rear, where there are no distractions from other colours. And her pink-toned colouring jars with it - as does her make-up. It would look a bit better if she was wearing a lipstick of a similar intensity, in a warm colour like rust or burgundy. But it still doesn't suit her.

However, I think we see colour differently!!!

Not seeing any of that. All I see is a more than averagely pretty young woman wearing a quite nice yellow coat.

Tbh I'm interested in clothes. I'm not remotely interested in analysing and criticising people's personal appearance in that way (even if I believed all that guff about "colours", which I don't.) This example confirms it's bollocks.

EleanorMc67 · Yesterday 16:50

MsMacheath · Yesterday 12:18

Not seeing any of that. All I see is a more than averagely pretty young woman wearing a quite nice yellow coat.

Tbh I'm interested in clothes. I'm not remotely interested in analysing and criticising people's personal appearance in that way (even if I believed all that guff about "colours", which I don't.) This example confirms it's bollocks.

Isn't the whole S&B board about analysing & critiquing* style/fashion/people's outfits (when they ask), & whether they work or not? You do that, I do that, others do that too.

*I feel that's an important differentiation, as critiquing relates to analysing both what works & what doesn't, with the aim of improvement. Criticising focuses purely on fault-finding & negatives.

I can't separate colour from my appreciation of clothes - it's nothing to do with "guff about colours" as I've been like that since I was a child. If I was faced with a dress I loved the shape & style of - but that only came in lime green, fuschia pink, lilac or bright yellow - I wouldn't even consider buying it. If it came in emerald green or inky blue or rusty red or black - I'd be spoilt for choice. I've never had my colours "done" - that's just a very visceral reaction to certain colours (wearing them, that is; I love & have bright pink & lilac tones in my home).

The more recent colour analysis fads (though starting in the 70s/80s I think?) do seem to often veer into bizarrely constraining advice - especially when they start to associate colours & styles with body types, which makes about as much sense as horoscopes! But at a basic level they're mostly just common sense to me.

I think that, at its absolute most basic principles, colour (theory) innately affects most of us, whether we know it or not. So did Aristotle, Newton & Van Gogh ...

You don't see anything jarring about that colour on the model. I do - as I said, we see colours differently.

MsMacheath · Yesterday 22:40

EleanorMc67 · Yesterday 16:50

Isn't the whole S&B board about analysing & critiquing* style/fashion/people's outfits (when they ask), & whether they work or not? You do that, I do that, others do that too.

*I feel that's an important differentiation, as critiquing relates to analysing both what works & what doesn't, with the aim of improvement. Criticising focuses purely on fault-finding & negatives.

I can't separate colour from my appreciation of clothes - it's nothing to do with "guff about colours" as I've been like that since I was a child. If I was faced with a dress I loved the shape & style of - but that only came in lime green, fuschia pink, lilac or bright yellow - I wouldn't even consider buying it. If it came in emerald green or inky blue or rusty red or black - I'd be spoilt for choice. I've never had my colours "done" - that's just a very visceral reaction to certain colours (wearing them, that is; I love & have bright pink & lilac tones in my home).

The more recent colour analysis fads (though starting in the 70s/80s I think?) do seem to often veer into bizarrely constraining advice - especially when they start to associate colours & styles with body types, which makes about as much sense as horoscopes! But at a basic level they're mostly just common sense to me.

I think that, at its absolute most basic principles, colour (theory) innately affects most of us, whether we know it or not. So did Aristotle, Newton & Van Gogh ...

You don't see anything jarring about that colour on the model. I do - as I said, we see colours differently.

There are colours I like and colours I don't like. I choose a colour because I like it-not because I think it will make me glow. I don't choose colours I don't like, simply because I don't like them, on me or anyone: not because they might make me look dead.

Your analysis of the model makes no sense to me at all. She is a more than averagely pretty and good looking young woman wearing an interesting coat.

In real life I look at the actual garment and think "wow/fab/ or bloody hell, what possessed you to buy that" I can't imagine in real life looking at someone and thinking "oh that colour drains you/looks terrible on you"

New posts on this thread. Refresh page