Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Which engagement ring would you choose?

20 replies

BritneyTheProphet · 20/10/2026 23:21

I’m looking for a new engagement ring. I know I want gold and an oval diamond. I can’t decide between these two. One is from Rox which I believe is a company that has stores in major cities and the other is in a jeweller independent to Leeds with a store in the trinity centre. I can’t understand why there is a £450 difference? I tried them both on and loved them both, the cheaper one will need a slight resize though.

Which engagement ring would you choose?
Which engagement ring would you choose?
Which engagement ring would you choose?
OP posts:
Hithismyname · 20/10/2026 23:28

I can see one is 18ct, is the other one also?

porridgewithsalt · 20/10/2026 23:28

The cheaper one from the local jeweller looks to be a slightly lower quality diamond as it is E v D (colour) and VS1 v VVS2 (clarity). But the difference is negligible and no-one including yourself will probably be able to tell. I'd go with the cheaper ring for that reason and also the service of a local independent.

BritneyTheProphet · 20/10/2026 23:33

@porridgewithsalt Yes, it’s 18ct too

OP posts:
thisismeithinkorisit · 20/10/2026 23:58

does the new fiance have a budget? I'd probably tell them this is what you like and let them ick if they're paying for it

Anonmousse · 20/10/2026 23:59

As @porridgewithsalt says the 2nd one is higher colour (slightly) and higher spec (slightly) and also v slightly bigger 1.55 or 1.56ct v 1.5ct.
But none of that would be noticeable by eye

Id say go for the cheaper one, and id expect them to resize it free of charge unless they needed to add gold to make it bigger.

jmh740 · 21/10/2026 00:09

Whats a lab grown diamond, is that why its cheaper?

FiveEightNine · 21/10/2026 00:22

jmh740 · 21/10/2026 00:09

Whats a lab grown diamond, is that why its cheaper?

Both are lab grown.

Diamonds come either from mining (which can be troublesome from ethics and ecology point of view) or from laboratory where huge pressure is used to force grafite to take diamond structure.

Mykittensaremyfriends · 21/10/2026 00:27

I’d go for the Rox because it doesn’t need resizing and it’s a bigger and higher quality diamond (clarity and colour). The gold band also looks the same width. Which is the other shop as there’s no independent jewellers inside the Trinity centre?

JillyComeLately · 21/10/2026 00:28

The rings are lovely and obviously far cheaper than mined diamonds.
But prices for lab grown are falling, apparently they have dropped 75% in 4 years, so personally, I wouldn't buy one.

Anonmousse · 22/10/2026 07:07

JillyComeLately · 21/10/2026 00:28

The rings are lovely and obviously far cheaper than mined diamonds.
But prices for lab grown are falling, apparently they have dropped 75% in 4 years, so personally, I wouldn't buy one.

Prices for Lab grown diamonds have fallen a lot, this has had an impact on the price of mined diamonds, which are also now cheaper. (Not by 75% though)
I dont think thr cost of LG diamonds will fall much further because there are still polishing, cutting and grading costs which are the same for both. LG have no resale value but hopefully thats not something people think about when they are getting engaged!

SummerT1me3 · 22/10/2026 07:17

I didn’t realise people bought lab grown diamonds as so many jewellers seem to have offers on whereby you receive a free lab grown diamond piece upon the purchase of a real diamond piece. Op is there a reason you want lab grown?

SucksToBeYou · 22/10/2026 07:35

On paper these two are very similar, with ROX having slightly better specifications.

One thing to note is that the local jeweller photo shows the oval cut bow tie effect, whereas you cant see that with the ROX photo, as its more of a stock image. It depends whether this is something that you are bothered about or not, but with a stock image you arent going to be able to see whether there is bow tie or windowing with that particular diamond.

JillyComeLately · 22/10/2026 23:19

Anonmousse · 22/10/2026 07:07

Prices for Lab grown diamonds have fallen a lot, this has had an impact on the price of mined diamonds, which are also now cheaper. (Not by 75% though)
I dont think thr cost of LG diamonds will fall much further because there are still polishing, cutting and grading costs which are the same for both. LG have no resale value but hopefully thats not something people think about when they are getting engaged!

Probably not, and they are identical to real diamonds.
But if anyone wants to buy a diamond as an investment, mined diamonds are a much safer long term bet.

Anonmousse · 23/10/2026 07:16

SummerT1me3 · 22/10/2026 07:17

I didn’t realise people bought lab grown diamonds as so many jewellers seem to have offers on whereby you receive a free lab grown diamond piece upon the purchase of a real diamond piece. Op is there a reason you want lab grown?

Of course people buy them, they are chemically and structurally the same material as a diamond, are indistinguishable by eye to a mined diamond, and a fraction of the price. And without all of the ethical concerns people have about mined diamonds

WhichCow · 23/10/2026 07:23

SummerT1me3 · 22/10/2026 07:17

I didn’t realise people bought lab grown diamonds as so many jewellers seem to have offers on whereby you receive a free lab grown diamond piece upon the purchase of a real diamond piece. Op is there a reason you want lab grown?

Of course people buy them. How silly.

SummerT1me3 · 23/10/2026 16:27

WhichCow · 23/10/2026 07:23

Of course people buy them. How silly.

Clearly not that silly as all the stores are giving them away for free!

Rossforthewin · 23/10/2026 16:39

i would only know if I tried it on. I have to see a ring on my finger to know how it sits before buying

WhichCow · 23/10/2026 16:43

SummerT1me3 · 23/10/2026 16:27

Clearly not that silly as all the stores are giving them away for free!

Clearly not all the stores given OP is looking to purchase one. Silly billy.

Arlanymor · 23/10/2026 16:49

Rossforthewin · 23/10/2026 16:39

i would only know if I tried it on. I have to see a ring on my finger to know how it sits before buying

Yes this, I know that you said you tried them both and liked them both @BritneyTheProphet, but the only way to tell is to see them on your hand. Also it's not very easy to compare a photo of an IRL ring and then a website image to be honest. It is, however, easy to tell why the Rox is more expensive based on the specs.

Thingsthatgo · 23/10/2026 16:51

Only buy an oval diamond if you have seen it in front of you with your own eyes. Oval diamonds (lab grown and mined) sometimes have a shadow in them called a Bow tie (it’s like two dark triangles in the middle of the oval). It’s not an inclusion, it’s a shadow caused by the way the stone is cut. ALWAYS look at an oval diamond carefully before buying.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread