Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Please work your magic and help me find the perfect cardigan.

62 replies

stealthsquirrelnutkin · 20/10/2026 16:34

I'm trying to find a cosy cardigan, in a deep, rich shade of green (bottle, forest end of the spectrum, not sage, moss or sea foam) in size 12 or 14.

Not acrylic or polyester, though a bit of nylon to help alpaca keep its shape is OK. Cashmere, mohair, merino, alpaca all preferred. Nothing "wool rich" that turns out to be only 14% wool and 86% plastic.

In summer I tend to wear those lacy cotton cardigans from Seasalt with the three quarter sleeves, but they are useless once there's a bit of a wind.

I've gone from a size 36 to a size 10/12 over the past 55 months, and am now at a stage where I am looking to buy stuff that will "see me out" - as gran used to say.

I was very tempted by this https://www.broraonline.com/en-gb/products/cashmere-cardigan-parsley-wpc2602c7151 but it is only available in size 8/10 and 16/18, I wanted the medium size 12/14 so there'd be plenty of room for extra layers underneath and although there is an option to be notified when the size is back in stock, I strongly suspect that when they do get new stock it will be at the full price of £495.00 rather than the £298.00 current offer.

I wouldn't normally consider paying 300 quid for a cardigan, but it's 6 ply pure Cashmere, and Brora have a good reputation for quality. I am tempted to order the size 8/10, but know myself too well. If I managed to button it up the front without stretching the button holes then I'd probably be seduced by the quality and keep it, even if it would be too tight to go over all the layers required to keep me warm. (Going from 73% body fat to 24% has me sitting here in cashmere wrist warmers and electrically heated slippers, despite the central heating being set at 22 degrees).

Personally I feel that a long cardigan with useful pockets (boyfriend style?) is better value than a neat fitted cardigan like the one linked above, but cropped and boxy cardigans seem to be fashionable at the moment.

Here's a link to the heated slippers, just in case any other Reynaud's sufferers are wondering. I just wish they hadn't sold out of spare battery packs because although the batteries last all day on the lower heat setting they take nearly five hours to fully recharge afterwards and I don't like leaving Chinese batteries unsupervised on the charger overnight.

edited to add the forgotten link. https://www.saviorheat.co.uk/products/sph203g3-smart-heated-slippers

Scottish Cashmere Cardigan in Parsley | Brora Sale

Expertly made in Scotland from world-class cashmere, our Cashmere Cardigan in Parsley is a layering essential for cooler evenings. Now in the Brora Sale.

https://www.broraonline.com/en-gb/products/cashmere-cardigan-parsley-wpc2602c7151

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
OhBuggerandArse · 20/10/2026 16:40

Brora sizing is tiny IME (standard size 10, medium often very neat/too small on me, though I have broad shoulders so that might be a factor) so it might even be worth trying the large size if you wouldn't be too depressed by the number on the label.

stealthsquirrelnutkin · 20/10/2026 17:21

Thanks, I suppose I could order the small and the large, to see if one of them fit, but there's a part of me that doesn't want to fork out £300 on a cardie that isn't perfect in every way.

I'm hoping someone will chime in with a link to the (affordable) cardigan of my dreams. Something with pockets and in the very greenest green.

OP posts:
StylishAndBeautiful · 20/10/2026 19:31

I don't rate Brora. Get a wool blend, it will be more moth-proof.

stealthsquirrelnutkin · 20/10/2026 20:48

That cashmere one from John Lewis looks appealing. At least I wouldn't feel impelled to change the buttons before wearing it, there was one I quite fancied that seemed to have leather footballs instead of buttons.

I really like the boxy Donegal cardie in that picture from Celtic & Co, but when I found it the description says that it is "deep Icelandic blue" and not the green that I see on my screen.

https://www.celticandco.com/products/donegal-boxy-cardi?variant=47482286571676

Currently trying to decide between the £99 John Lewis cashmere from the link above, and this 3 ply cashmere that is exactly the right shade of green.

https://www.houseofbruar.com/l-csh-3ply-gold-btn-cdgn-green-tt92142bottle/

I'll sleep on it tonight and decide tomorrow, if I go for the cheaper green cardie I might be able to afford this as well.

https://www.gudrunsjoden.com/en-gb/clothes/cardigans/cardigan-knitted-from-an-alpaca-blend-burnt-orange-l

Donegal Boxy Cardigan | Celtic & Co.

Discover the Donegal Boxy Cardigan, crafted from 100% Donegal wool with a stylish boxy fit, saddle shoulder detail, and practical front pockets for effortless everyday layering.

https://www.celticandco.com/products/donegal-boxy-cardi?variant=47482286571676

OP posts:
estrella167532839 · 20/10/2026 21:25

I usually get cardigans from Zara, Mango and Tu at Sainsbury’s.

StylishAndBeautiful · 20/10/2026 21:38

Sea Green | Cashmere Crew Neck Cardigan | WoolOvers UK

StylishAndBeautiful · 20/10/2026 21:41

Khaki | Cashmere Merino Crew Neck Cardigan | WoolOvers UK

venus7 · 20/10/2026 21:51

estrella167532839 · 20/10/2026 21:25

I usually get cardigans from Zara, Mango and Tu at Sainsbury’s.

They rarely use natural fibres......op wants cashmere or merino.

venus7 · 20/10/2026 21:52

John Smedley make beautiful knitwear, often long line
cardigans.

SpringingOn · 20/10/2026 21:53

Oh the burnt orange one linked is lovely - although I am tempted by the heather one.

Mamamia35 · 20/10/2026 22:00

My favourite is the Celtic and Co one. I’d also recommend the premium range by H&M - though they are lacking green… but their jumpers are very good quality for the price. Cos but not Cos pricing.

Doggymummar · 20/10/2026 22:04

The Celtic and co ones are the ones I'm after tho I saw a couple on eBay earlier let me see if I can find the links. https://ebay.io/m/298b1E

semideponent · 20/10/2026 22:55

You could look at Aethel, who offer a v-neck and round neck cardigan. The v neck comes in a proper deep spruce green. The cashmere I've bought there has been thick and good quality.

Floristian · 20/10/2026 22:58

venus7 · 20/10/2026 21:52

John Smedley make beautiful knitwear, often long line
cardigans.

And if you live anywhere near Derbyshire, they've got a great factory shop.

waltzingparrot · 21/10/2026 00:14

Have a look at Peruvian Connection. They do 100% Alpaca knitwear, including baby Alpaca (ah).

EleanorMc67 · 21/10/2026 03:21

Bloody hell, OP - I thought I'd misread the number at first - but you've gone from a size 36 to a 10/12?!! That's fantastic - congratulations!

I think the Brora one is an absolutely delicious shade of green - & I like your phrase "the greenest green"! I think of it as a "perfect green" or "universal green" - as it's not too intense or too muted, too blue- or too yellow-toned, & suits most people.

It might well come back in as a return in the medium, so it's worth signing up for notifications. But also, I would phone customer service to see if they can find out if it's in stock in one of their shops (there are eight plus an outlet store in the UK). If they're not able to find out, I would phone each store individually ...

(I am seriously tempted by it myself ... especially since my old neighbour now manages one of their London stores & might just get me a further discount ... 🤔)

EleanorMc67 · 21/10/2026 03:32

stealthsquirrelnutkin · 20/10/2026 20:48

That cashmere one from John Lewis looks appealing. At least I wouldn't feel impelled to change the buttons before wearing it, there was one I quite fancied that seemed to have leather footballs instead of buttons.

I really like the boxy Donegal cardie in that picture from Celtic & Co, but when I found it the description says that it is "deep Icelandic blue" and not the green that I see on my screen.

https://www.celticandco.com/products/donegal-boxy-cardi?variant=47482286571676

Currently trying to decide between the £99 John Lewis cashmere from the link above, and this 3 ply cashmere that is exactly the right shade of green.

https://www.houseofbruar.com/l-csh-3ply-gold-btn-cdgn-green-tt92142bottle/

I'll sleep on it tonight and decide tomorrow, if I go for the cheaper green cardie I might be able to afford this as well.

https://www.gudrunsjoden.com/en-gb/clothes/cardigans/cardigan-knitted-from-an-alpaca-blend-burnt-orange-l

I really like the Celtic & Co one too. I think they've just called it that as it's on the cool spectrum of greens, so has a lot of blue in it (as opposed to olive or khaki, which lean yellow not blue). Definitely worth a try, especially as you'll be layering it (some people find Donegal wool scratchy on its own, as it's coarser). I am tempted by it too ...

The JL one is a nice ordinary cardigan. The HoB one is dated looking - both the fit & the buttons (which I dislike). Finer cardigans won't layer as well on top either - they'll look lumpy, & are better as a layer below. Both the Brora or Celtic & Co cardigans are more contemporary in style & will layer on top of other things well. Track down the Brora one, & order the Celtic & Co one - & compare & choose one (or both as they're lovely & not very similar!).

Yello24 · 21/10/2026 06:16

Current fashion is unusually short/cropped/boxy so if you want it forever I’d actually go more classic. Plus it’s warmer!
Woolovers good value for the fibre and quality.

Petitchouchou · 21/10/2026 07:39

If you’re looking for a cardigan that will see you out, then some of the Brora ones are worth the spend, but as @OhBuggerandArse says, the sizing is very neat. I’m a 10 and would choose a medium or a 12/14 in their cropped or plain cardigans.