Can anyone recommend a liquid eye serum that does not pill?

[WaneyEdge]

Are there any eye serums that are liquid rather than cream/gel? Every single cream or gel pills on me. Every. Single. One. It’s so bloody annoying and takes my makeup with it on days I wear it. I’m looking for something that’s liquid like a toner/serum that I can pat in and it’s not lying on top of my skin.

The best one I’ve ever used years ago was the Environ C-Quence but that’s £££ and not sure I could justify it if it’s not as good as I remember!

Are you possibly using too much? I’ve used various different high quality and M & S etc and never had a problem. Have had this happen with face creams if I’ve put too much on.

I don’t think so? I’ve used various creams over the years, tried using not much or lots and the end result is the same. It’s like it never properly gets absorbed and just sits there.

I use a Lancôme liquid one but only have it on at bedtime

I use the Clinique all about eyes serum, it’s got a little roller ball to apply. I’ve not had any problems with my makeup when using it

I use an eye serum from a small British brand called Base Skincare, no pilling with make up over the top.

https://www.baseskncare.co.uk/products/miracle-eye-complex

You only need a tiny bit near your eyes. I have 4 layers of serum/creams near my eyes and it doesn’t pill.

It might not be the eye serum itself, but what you’re layering it with in terms of moisturisers/primers/make up. This is about foundation pilling, but the principles are the same when you’re working out what products will pair well with other products: https://labmuffin.com/fixing-foundation-clumping-with-video/#Test_out_the_product_combinationproducts

Laneige water bank eye cream and the ordinary peptide eye serum

https://www.boots.com/clinique-all-about-eyes-massage-serum-15ml-10287038?traffic=paid.shopping&gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=23431343481&gbraid=0AAAAA-AdmwQ0p9zqphlxoqqJ_TOBtksp3&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIzLfkuaKtlAMVm4NQBh3z3Ce1EAQYASABEgLeO_D_BwE