Stuck between 2 bags?

[Barrenfieldoffucks]

Any opinions welcomed!

First one:

https://www.whitestuff.com/p/3254/fern-crossbody/DK_BROWN

Second one:

https://www.allsaints.com/women/sale/luna-slouchy-leather-shoulder-bag/W190XD-104.html

I wouldn’t buy the white stuff one. I hate deep bags with a narrow opening, as I can never find anything. Tbf I couldn’t afford the all saints one, so would keep looking in your shoes

You can shorten it, you get a cobbler to put more holes in for the buckle. I’ve done this on mine. Having said that, I don’t love the bag, it’s too long and the zip is rough and hard to use. Wish I hadn’t bought it.

I misread the title, as I tired and honestly thought you meant stuck between 2 old bags 😆
I had visions of you being on a bus or train and 2 old biddy's talking crap about how rude young ones are today etc 😆 🤣 😂

That enough Internet for me today. 🤦🏻‍♀️

I have the all saints one in black and I love it! The leather is ridiculously soft and it’s so practical.

More money than sense paying nearly £200 for a bag that size..yes I love Bags and shoes/boots and have loads and had to sell and giveaway loads when moving house recently but not in today's economy would I pay that for a bag..

All Saints one imo is more dressy.
I find White Stuff overrated, overpriced and frumpy like they're palming us old birds off with old women clothes. (I'm 54). But trying to make out it's exciting. It's not it's dull., dull, dull. I'm not down with the kids but I'm not being fooled by Whitestuff.

100% the Allsaints one. The White Stuff one looks really boring and I hate the lining.

Yeah the lining on the WS bag is so shit. What made them think that was a good choice?!

I’m not a massive fan of either but if I had to choose I prefer the All Saints. Bear in mind however that the style will date quickly. It’s not a classic shape.

I started a thread recently as I too was trying to decide between two bags!
In your case OP, I prefer the All Saints bag.