Is Victoria Bekham eyeliner all that?

[LoraPiano]

Been on the lookout for a new eyeliner, and the VB one has been reommended so many times. Quite expensive so wondering if it is that good? Any experience with it?

I have the cocoa. Gorgeous colour, but doesn't stay put. It goes on beautifully, but because it's so soft, you have to constantly sharpen it.

Lots of people love them but I hated them unfortunately. Way too soft, the smudger broke in the lid of one of mine (the first one I bought) so that was redundant. The liner is really greasy and just not what I was looking for. The colours I had were beautiful but they were just a nightmare to apply. And sharpening them was a joke!
Probably need to put it in the fridge for an hour before even attempting it.

I was unimpressed. It started well, went on smoothly and a lovely colour (cocoa) but the colour didn’t last, and when I needed to sharpen it, the end kept breaking off. I ended up throwing it away!

Following as I love the look so hope you get recommended a good alternative.

I am on my third cocoa. Love it. And the vast lash mascara

I didn't get on with it at all. I tried Cocoa, which was a lovely colour, but a nightmare to apply. I also bought one of their sharpeners but it didn't work. I emailed Customer service to explain, and they said the blade needed tightening and I should do it myself. I didn't have a screwdriver small enough so gave up.

I now use Wonderskin eyeliner and find it much better.

I love them!

Different shades last better than others. Olive and ash are lovely but I’ve had the Bordeaux one twice and each time it was rubbish.

I love the Zoeva ones more for ‘colours’ but Dior makes the best black eyeliner.

I've given up on mine too, it manages to both drag and be too soft and smudgy. Not a fan

I love mine and have a variety of colours

IME a hard (or rather soft) no.

It’s so soft I had to put it in the fridge before sharpening it. Also so soft it’s hard to control.

Was very disappointed and binned it.

I have the olive, ash & navy.

Theyre beautiful but darker than they appear on the adverts.

go on beautifully too. Need topping up a bit though.

I wear eyeliner daily and the best ones i have tried are Avon glimmersticks , they are pretty much smudge proof , after trying so many different ones over many years i am reluctant to try any other makes now.

I look at the colours and the softness and blendability. I'd always worn black but it was starting to look a bit harsh as was a hard line. I'd tried brown in the past but they were too light But the cocoa one is lovely as is the olive

Love it, the cocoa specifically, blends fantastically and is by far my favourite, I haven't had the issue of needing to reapply, but I use primer, conceler foundation, and setting spray so I find it stays put and blends beautifully. Only downside is because the product is very soft and easy to blend, I find it gets used up much quicker than other eyeliners meaning that the higher cost, is even higher realistically.

Thanks all. I am still in two minds. Any other eyeliners you recommend? I have been using hourglass, but it is expensive for the amount and keeps breaking.

Everybody said it’s the best eyeliner ever. I bought one and it’s a smudgy prince of shit.

I have a Victoria Beckham eyeliner and a Hildun eyeliner- both written about as the “bees knees”of eye liners.
I also have Boots No 7 eyeliners.
All three brands are made in Germany.
All three brands are equally soft.
All three are at different price points.
Check out Boots No7 and Hildun @LoraPiano

Another Avon one i swear by is Power stay 16 hour shadow stick in mocha brew a lovely dark chocolate brown , lets you create a finer line or you can smudge it into your lid ,it also looks really good with a slight cats eye flick at the end, it never budges on me.

I bought the VB ash one when it was on a weekend offer. I really like it, but I use it on the waterline, rather than as a flicky liner. It stays put really well. I even slept in it once and it was still sitting nicely on the waterline next morning.

I love my Charlotte Tilbury ones. I have on in a soft almost coppery brown and it’s tiny now and I need to replace. I also have a lovely navy colour. Sorry can’t remember the colour name.

It’s (for me) a perfect consistency. Soft enough to slide on without dragging (and smoke out if you wish) but hard enough to create a defined line.

You get about a minute of play time then it sets and stays put.

I also like her colour chameleon sticks (basically a chunky eyeliner come eyeshadow). I have 4 different colours and they are especially good if you are a bit cack handed with eyeliner (like me - I can do it but it takes time and the sticks are much better/easier if I’m in a hurry).

I hated it. Went on well but spread down my face to the point I looked like Alice Cooper 🤣🤣 The Trinny one is much better for me.

I’ve got one, it’s ok but I wouldn’t repurchase, expensive but to be fair it’s a longer than average pencil, I’ve found Sephora own brand pencil eye liner a similar soft smudgy texture.

I've got lots and I love them. Not had any of the issues mentioned here. Beautiful colours and they stay put fine for me. Although I do agree they need sharpening often.

I've worn eyeliner pretty much every day since I was about 16, so have used lots of different ones, and these are among my favourites. I also like Bobbi Brown, but they've got rid of the best shade, which was a shimmery bronze, think it's only black and brown now.

I use Bobbi Brown gel eyeliner, it stays on even when I fall in the water from a paddleboard or sweat in the gym. I use black or chocolate shimmer depending on what I'm doing.