I needed a new brown mascara and checked out threads to try and find a replacement for the Benefit They're Real and Better Than Sex that I've loved. The Elf one was recommended so for £6 I thought I'd give it a go. I wanted waterproof due to spending a lot of time outside in the rain and someone said tubing mascara is waterproof to 37C. I hastily tried it last night. I woke up this morning and it's still in place apart from a few tiny flakes. I'm impressed! Given more careful application I think I'll be a total convert to this. Thank you for the suggestion😃 just need to work on my eyebrows...