After 25 years I have found the holy grail mascara.
And believe you me I have tried them all
Clinique Lash Power tubing was the best until now (but doesn't really lengthen)
I have also tried
Lancôme Hypnose
EL
Benefit
L'oriel
Hourglass
Dior
You name it and 100s (probably 1000s of £)
Boots no 7 tubing mascara also has previously been good but then they changed the formula (with new packaging)
But this is the best of the lot: No 7 Extreme Length Waterproof
(From a contact lens wearing oily person- I thought I would share!!)