High Street eye pencil / liner suggestions please

[GingerbicciesPlease]

Mine's just run out - didn't expect that- it was Clinique in Chocolate. I've also used B Brown (the one that is their gel eyeliner but a pencil.)

I will replace but only when there is a discount.

So...what would you suggest?

I will be limited to the usual brands - Rimmel, L Oreal, Elf, etc.

I want something that's creamy and soft not a hard pencil.

Watching with interest. I found the perfect eye pencil through a cosmetics box scheme but it's been discontinued! All the ones I try smudge or are too hard going on. The one I had was perfect.

I've gone from the Chanel Kohl (used for years) to the L'Oréal paradise kohl and it's fab!

Shade espresso

@thedendrochronologist Just to say THANKS. I've bought it and so far, it's good! Saved me £20 on my Clinique or Bobbi Brown.

Maybelline gel liner is great and has a smudger and a sharpener

@GingerbicciesPlease

That's great

Happy to have helped!

Avon glimmerstick is fabulous.

@marshmallowfinder
Yes it is! I normally buy cosmic brown or black/brown - usually 3 at a time from Amazon.