Anyone have a Dupe for body shop beech lip liner?

[Dannexe]

I’ve used this since I was a teenager and it seems to be discontinued. Before I go dropping £25 on one of the last two in the country does anyone have a good dupe for it? It’s basically a soft long lasting lipliner in a neutral “lip colour” pink

Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk might work. It’s worth trying it in store somewhere.
Its a bit more pink than the lipstick in the same shade, so don’t let that put you off.
I hate it when my favourites are discontinued. So annoying!

It’s really frustrating. Even more so because I have a facial palsy which means it takes a lot of work to make my lips look vaguely even. If I use a shade that is too bright it shows it up even more..

ridiculously, buying Charlotte Tilbury would be cheaper than buying the last body shop lip liner on eBay!

That is ridiculous!
I think Charlotte Tilbury make up is rather overpriced but I do like this lipliner.

Revlon Colorstay lipliner in nude is what I use now Beech is discontinued! It's the closest thing I've found. However, stocks always seem to be low in Boots so it's either super popular or also on the list if products being discontinued. Deffo recommend though!

NYX Soft Brown or Natural might work, I am also a fan of BS Beech.

Gutted this has been discontinued, it’s been my go to liner since I was a teenager 😥 You could try Milani Lip Liner in shade Spice (Boots & Beauty Bay have it), Charlotte Tilbury in Iconic Nude or MAC Spice. Hope this helps x

Hi, I was just searching for the beech lipliner too, and was wondering if you tried any of the ones suggested in the comments, did any come close?

Maybe see if you can get it on Amazon???

I’ve been using nyx nude. Its ok. Its much harder than the body shop one and its more grey in tone but its ok. It’s certainly not a dupe