Dupes for VB Beauty Satin Kajal liner?

[Ringsender2]

I keep getting ads for the Vic Beck Beauty kajhal satin eyeliner.

Anyone good on dupes? Colours of partic interest are the sea grey and bronze, also the olive.

Bit on the pricey side for buying on a whim, and I'm not sure where stocks it near me anyway.

Same, I bought a rimmel one on amazon which was very cheap but it's lighter than the VB bronze

thanks @C0mfyChairP0se I'll have a browse in Boots/ beauty counters in the nearest dept store cosmetics hall next weekend I think...

I brought the VB from ebay a travel size one, I wish I hadn't bothered, it smudges so badly hardly lasted on the water line more than 20 minutes

It's shit so don't feel like you are missing out. NYX perform better.

oh wow, thanks @lindyloo57 and @Sparkletastic for that feedback. Will look out Nyx. Thank you!

Sorry I made a mistake its the charlotte tilbury one i brought thats rubbish, I couldn't chose between them , now seeing other reviews for the VB I won't bother with it.

(I may regret posting this...)
Don't know what that is but I have been using Barry M (cruelty free!!) metallic green and silver eyeliners (more dark grey than silver) for £4.99 and they are fabulous! Don't budge.
I snaffles a load of them this week.

Avon Supershock gel eyeliners are virtually identical to the VB eyeliner. I have both and Avon gets my money.