if someone were to buy you an expensive coat, which of these two would you choose?

[VermiciousKnid]

(btw, you're a sahm)

this

or

this

hobbs

first one and i am a sahm that wears jeans

its a lovely coat enjoy it

god hobbs is especially old lady at the mo isn't it

Hobbs are good but a teensy bit middle aged?

I speak as one who shops there all the time (hastily not wanting to offend)

Don't you think the Karen Millen coats are lovely?

Burberry's supposed to be making a valiant comeback, I spose.

Neither, sorry but think neither look like flattering cuts.

I'm not keen on either of the burberry ones,although if I had to pick it would be the first one.
I prefer the Karen Millen ones.

Ridiculous prices for the burberry ones imo.

first one is lovely but I wouldn;t buy it, I wouldn't feel particularly comfortable in it - it's basically too, what I would call, posey. and also too expensive - I just couldn;t justify it to myself.

Number one looks gorgeous.

Don't like either - the first one looks like a military coat, and don't like the collar, the second one looks a bit like a shell suit!

I'd look for the same style eslewhere but cheaper so I could have both. One is casual, the other smart.

But the white one is dry clean only ... h'm ...

the first one

tbh neither

I've seen much nicer coats for the money

the colour of the first one is hideous and would nothing for anyone unless maybe if you were very dark skinned

would love the first one but would probably get dirty really fast

think the first one would smarten up a not too smart outfit, but with the second you would really need to have nice clothes underneath to pull it off....
(by smart I do of course mean well cut jeans not covered in snot/banana/yoghurt/puke/chocolate, etc with good shoes/boots....)

Message withdrawn

first one but I'd check the neck, that's a very high collar and might be uncomfortable if you need to look down!

first one. second one looks like it comes from somewhere cheap and chav (and you would go off it)

first one definately and would look lovely with anything and everything.

Message withdrawn

First one is much nicer and more classic (don't like the colour of either of them though, but like the cut).

Fuck me, just seen the price!!!!!!!!!!!!

I would ask them to get down to the Hobbs sale and buy me one of their fab coats....

First one
Second one looks like it was made from a cheap duvet