eyeliner pencil that stays put

[queenofgoogle]

I'm looking for an eye liner pencil not gel or pen that will stay on all day. preferably lower end like Maybeliine or Rimmel etc.
I currently use Rimmel Le khol,but it doesn't stay on very well.
Has anyone tried anything else that would stay on or do I have to use a pen liner?
I prefer the softer look of a pencil

I discovered Mally a few weeks ago and their eyeliners are amazing for staying put. Not cheap cheap but not super expensive, either.

I've not heard of Mally before I'll give them a Google.thanks

mallys a bit out of my price range for an eyeliner pencil.
does anyone have any other recommendations?

Estee lauder double wear eye pencil. Stays put and will last approximately 2 years with daily use.

Rimmel scandeleyes waterproof khol

NYX is the one ive been using,i think its £6 x

www.boots.com/cyo-setting-our-sights-kohl-gel-eyeliner-10239336

These are excellent.

I second the Mally ones, they stay soft in the pencil even after having them for a few months. I got my last one new off ebay, it is a lovely brown colour.

i just sent my mally order back to QVC, i found the mally liners no good for me, i only ordered them as mally said they were bullet proof, my eyelids must be very oily as i have tried so many pencils, and not one stays put on me.

Second the Rimmel waterproof one

I’ve tried them all.
Bobbi brown long lasting eye pencil in grey or mahogany.
It is amazing. I get asked about it all the time.
It endures sea swimming, Sup, and running yet comes off with my Chanel eye makeup remover in one sweep