Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

M&S hall of fame summer 2018

31 replies

TheVastMajority · 08/05/2018 12:24

I give you this monstrosity. It is even more horrendous in real life.

www.marksandspencer.com/colour-block-velvet-tunic-maxi-dress/p/p60136385?image=SD_01_T42_8079T_F4_X_EC_90&color=NAVYMIX&prevPage=plp

Honorable mentions:

Makes even the model look chunky...

www.marksandspencer.com/pure-cotton-drawcord-swing-dress/p/p60157471?image=SD_01_T42_8110T_R0_X_EC_90&color=YELLOW&prevPage=plp&pdpredirect

just....no.

www.marksandspencer.com/floral-print-scoop-neck-tunic-maxi-dress/p/p60166402?image=SD_01_T42_8104T_S9_X_EC_90&color=LIGHTTANMIX&prevPage=plp

and finally....for when you want to look like ANdy Pandy (showing my age)...

www.marksandspencer.com/pure-cotton-embroidered-tunic-dress/p/p60156494?image=SD_01_T42_9008_E4_X_EC_90&color=BLUEMIX&prevPage=plp

Otherwise, some of their stuff is quite nice this year!

OP posts:
sufferingaggressiveneighbours · 08/05/2018 13:14

Crikey, that first dress is totally, totally shocking - the sort of thing once you have seen you cannot unsee!

What have you seen that is nice this year? No, I am not being facetious, just that I have not visited in a while.

I am usually a big M&S fan. Dare I admit I used to be on their consumer panel and gave feedback on new ranges? They seem to have stopped that now (or maybe they have screened me out!) and just seem to send out irritating on -line questionnaires. Mmmm...could be part of their current problems.

MayFayner · 08/05/2018 13:23

The last one is a dress I had when I was 3, my mum sewed it for me herself.

The peachy one is reminiscent of the dressing-up box.

The yellow one is nearly ok! But then isn't.

The first one is beyond hideous.

ppeatfruit · 08/05/2018 13:53

Sorry I don't click on links, I popped in a month ago (Oxford St) And was open mouthed at all the baggy nappy trousers they had fgs!!!! How many of their customers would buy them ? i guarantee they'll have the majority of them left on the hangers.

I looked for their size 10 plain COTTON T shirts, there were no 10s left so I bought 12s which fitted fine. They are ok. They re STILL not aiming at their ideal customer who like their basics , not outlandish prints and baggy crotch trousers!!!!

SpanxOnLetsGo · 08/05/2018 14:02

Wow.

I think I'd pair the first dress with these: gorgeous

or perhaps these: special

sufferingaggressiveneighbours · 08/05/2018 14:17

Yes those shoes would go really well .

Gingernaut · 08/05/2018 14:36

i dropped over £150 in M&S Leeds this weekend.

On a couple of these black and aqua www.marksandspencer.com/mid-rise-super-skinny-leg-cropped-jeans/p/p60153631?image=SD_01_T57_5110_XB_X_EC_90&color=INDIGO&prevPage=plp

One of these www.marksandspencer.com/cotton-rich-embroidered-short-sleeve-t-shirt/p/p60168261?image=SD_01_T41_6149_E4_X_EC_90&color=BLUEMIX&prevPage=plp

One of these also aqua www.marksandspencer.com/pure-linen-long-sleeve-shirt/p/p60130088?image=SD_01_T43_1160_J9_X_EC_90&color=MEDIUMAQUA&prevPage=plp

One of these www.marksandspencer.com/pure-silk-floral-print-scarf/p/p60137252?image=SD_01_T01_6555T_K0_X_EC_90&color=CREAM&prevPage=plp

One of these www.marksandspencer.com/pure-silk-printed-scarf/p/p60159339?image=SD_01_T01_6597T_T4_X_EC_90&color=GREYMIX&prevPage=plp

And one of these in navy www.marksandspencer.com/pure-linen-wide-leg-flared-trousers/p/p60156768?image=SD_01_T57_7036_F0_X_EC_90&color=NAVY&prevPage=plp although cropped will be ankle length....

I don't know who is designing for Marks and Spencer and I don't know who they're designing for, but the sleeves are weird - either too short or too long, the waists are too high or too low, the lengths are either too short or too long, the styles are oddly infantile and the patterns look like they were put together by the colourblind.

VladPutin · 08/05/2018 14:42

I tried the dress on in the op. It wasn’t as bad as I’d thought. 🙄

M&S hall of fame summer 2018
VladPutin · 08/05/2018 14:45

Ooh. And the peach one too. Coincidentally

VladPutin · 08/05/2018 14:46

The. Worst.

M&S hall of fame summer 2018
ppeatfruit · 08/05/2018 14:53

We've had threads like this one for years and they still haven't taken our ideas on board , it's not surprising they're still losing money. They have no real direction.

It seemed as if they've changed the vanity sizes to a bit smaller, anyone else agree or have I put on weight? Grin Although interestingly I asked for their casual trouser section and I was pointed in the direction of the droopy nappy trousers! oh dear!

dontticklethetoad · 08/05/2018 15:01

I have bought this. I look hideous. Although I think it probably has more to do with my boobs.

M&S hall of fame summer 2018
BluthsFrozenBananas · 08/05/2018 15:18

Why do m and s keep churning out dresses designed to make the wearer look like an extra in Abigail's Party? They seem obsessed with taking the worst kind of 70s maxi dresses and recreating them, I honestly can't work out their business plan.

VladPutin · 08/05/2018 15:38

Your mistake with that dress and boobs are the sleeves. End at boob height which makes the appearance of a line across you.

ppeatfruit · 08/05/2018 16:00

Bluths I don't keep up with the latest Paris or Brit fashions but I reckon that there are young buyers working for M&S who DO and think that's what their customers want fgs.

They haven't noticed that the people who ARE very fashion conscious fashion victims. Don't shop in M&S they shop in the shit shops like Primark who employ children in China, Indonesia etc. churning out the very latest fashions ALL the time.

ppeatfruit · 08/05/2018 16:05

I was pleased to see that the cotton T shirts I bought were made with 'carefully sourced' cotton ,or something like that, (it wasn't clear what they meant but it pleased me Grin )

I was also pleased that they were making Tshirts from recycled polyester or something, I wouldn't wear them, but a good idea.

phoolani · 08/05/2018 16:06

I quite like op’s yellow dress. The peach one would look good on a youngster at a festival - I can see what they’re aiming at (not sure it’s a good idea, mind you).
On the plus side, I have these and they’re lovely www.marksandspencer.com/leather-two-band-sandals-with-insolia-flex/p/p60160009?image=SD_01_T02_2970_Y4_X_EC_90&color=BLACKMIX&prevPage=plp

Ohyesiam · 08/05/2018 16:09

I wonder if the yellow one is m&s trying to do Cos.

japanesegarden · 08/05/2018 16:11

I went into a largish local branch last week. I wanted a plain black nightie, perhaps with a little bit of lace, knee length. I am 53 and wanted a nightie because I get too hot in pyjamas, knee length because I am 53, and plain black because I am a grownup and wanted something classic and adult without being either very sexy or cutesy. There.were.no.black.nighties.at.all. In fact, there were no plain nighties at all except old lady textured thick cotton ones in white. Almost everything was pyjamas, had weird or cute logos or prints on, or sprigs of flowers. I had a quick look at the day clothes and saw nothing I'd have been willing to wear. I should be their ideal customer - middle aged, middle class, like clothes up to a point but not high fashion, would have spent a couple of hundred if I'd seen several things I liked. As it was, I bought some plain black pants for £7 and nothing else. I would rather have paid twice as much for the pants and know they hadn't been produced in a sweatshop in Bangladesh, but that wasn't an option.
Really, they deserve to go bust. Their clothing strategies have been so bad for so long that it's completely incomprehensible.

ppeatfruit · 08/05/2018 16:20

Japanese I know exactly what you mean but perhaps you were there in the wrong season , maybe they only do black for winter or something. I know that when I was there in early April it was towards the end of their summer season because there were rails of unwearable swimsuits!

Talking about swimsuits when will they make an all in one with a proper bra fastening ? It can't be beyond them, they make bras for gods sake. I saw one in a classy little underwear shop in dms village but it was £160 and I didn't want to spend that much at the time!

BigGreenOlives · 08/05/2018 16:25

@phoolani one of my friends had last year’s version of those and loved them.

StrangeOddment · 08/05/2018 16:46

I bought those linen trousers the other day Ginger! As long as we don't go to the same office parties we'll probably be ok Grin

I considered the white linen trousers but they looked totally see through. Hmm

Apparently white trousers which have a lining are a step too far for M&S.

ppeatfruit · 08/05/2018 20:07

Oh god Strange You reminded about being in an informal restaurant a month ago in the West End and one of the customers walked in, in a very 'look at me' way; she wearing what looked like completely see through white linen trousers (from the back Grin ) She was tall and plasticised in high heeled boots , thick fake hair pieces, she proceeded to film her food. I was trying to work out what she was and I gave up!

StrangeOddment · 09/05/2018 10:00

Instagrammer maybe ppeatfruit? Snapchatter? Maybe a YouTuber? Vloggers usually film sitting down so it doesn't matter if they aren't wearing trousers are see-through at the back.

I used to love the M&S skinny jeans. Nice and thick, front and back pockets...the new jeggings are ok but the stitching on the pockets (only back pockets) is rubbish, to the point that I nearly lost my keys in the supermarket car park the other day. A lady had to stop me with 'did you know your keys are hanging out the bottom of your pocket?'

No. No I did not.

Gingernaut · 09/05/2018 10:23

The M&S Leeds is a big store, but not so big that they had enough hanger options for every style of jeans and casual trousers.

Skinny mid rise, skinny mid rise cropped, skinny mid rise short, super skinny mid rise, super skinny mid rise cropped, jeggings, high rise mom, kick flare, bootcut, Per Una, Classic, M&S Collection all with short, regular, long options with some super short as well.

It didn't help that there were casual, jeans and some trousers downstairs, but when I asked about a particular type of jeans, the staff referred me to women's trousers UPSTAIRS.

A head splitting collection of trousers downstairs and even more upstairs.

There's too much to take on board without some sort of guide easily accessible from the point you walk through the doors.

ppeatfruit · 09/05/2018 10:30

Yes maybe Strange Grin She very much wanted everyone to see her !! (i must say she had a fantastic body in those trousers) . They looked lined but who knows Grin

gingernaut Yes that was just the same in Oxford St. madness! Did they have those baggy nappy crotch trousers everywhere too?