A good mascara

[Rathkelter]

Has anyone got the magic product I need?
Here's my criteria:
-Doesn't clump lashes
-Doesn't leave black dots under your eye when you go out in the drizzle
-comes off easily with an oil-free remover- the only one I have ever used that doesn't sting my eyes is Body Shop Camomile but I'm up for suggestions.

Am with the people saying Lancome Hypnose (the original one, NOT any of the Drama etc. variations). About £23 or so I think? But HoF and Debenhams etc often seem to do deals!

Clinique Lash Power. It doesn't shift other than with warm water, stays put through rain, contact lenses, gym class, the lot. I won't buy anything else.

Maybelline in the green and pink tube is fab. I use ponds cold cream to remove it.

Max Factor Masterpiece Max.

Think I say this in every mascara thread, but Clinique full to flutter is great. It's a tubing mascara so it doesn't budge once on and you use warm water to remove it.

I found the No 7 gold one very clumpy. It does stay put though.

I like Estée Lauder double wear mascara - goes on evenly and I never get smudges or panda eyes!

My DD (who has naturally long curled eyelashes ) likes Tarte Tartiest and Too Faced Better Than Sex .

I have The Worlds Worst eyelashes, I'm using Kiko (fibres, silver tube) and their dual layer non oily remover. With a squeeze of the curlers beforehand and two thin layers they look presentable .

I find the m and s ones to be as good as Lancôme and half the price.

Lash princess by essence is amazing,I get it from wilkos, again £3!!

I like Maybelline great lash - cheap & cheerful but does the job. It comes in Waterproof version too.