Superdrug hot cloth cleanser. Vote. Vitamin E or radiance?

[Evvy543]

I'm going to buy one, can't decide though!
Which is better?

hi Evvy543, I have used both products in the last two weeks. imo the vit E is much better,nicer fragrance and not too thick.The radiance cleanser had a funny smell that I just couldn't take too.

The Vitamin E is lovely, smells nice, and feels gentle and creamy.

I resisted it for ages because of the hideousness of the Radiance. Yuck. Smells really synthetic and overpowering and leaves (my) skin tight and itchy followed, 3 days later, by attractive rosacea breakouts.

The E is fab. I alternate (or double cleanse) with that, and Body Shop Chamomile butter.

Is it as good as Liz Earle (as I've heard)?

I've got Liz Earle. Dd has Superdrug Vit E. I won't be buying LE again

I don't think so, no.

I like both, the Superdrug is a good budget one.

Liz Earle is in a different league because of the quality of the essential oils I think. They don't agree with everyone, and I know LE C&P is very marmite on here, but to compare it with the godawful Radiance range in Superdrug is bizarre.

(the BS Chamomile butter is better than all of them!)

(I would buy the Vit E over LE, because it's great, and cheap)

I can't use C&P anymore. Of the two Superdrug ones I prefer Vitamin E to the Radiance one, it suits my sensitive skin much better.

Radiant one for me, I'm on at least my 10th tube. Wasn't a fan of the smell of the vitamin E one. Very dry, not sensitive skin.

The cheapness of it allows me to justify owning the Emma Harvie cleanser, which is the nicest thing I've ever put on my face.

I thought Liz Earle was fine but nothing special for my skin.

I use the radiance one. Love it.

Another vote for the vit E one here. I've used both. I tend to buy whichever one is on offer because I'm a cheapskate, but all things being equal I prefer the vit E one.

I use the Radiance one all the time (stock up when it's on BOGOF), but I may try the Vit E one next time just 'cos I'm getting a bit bored of using the same thing! I got given some of the Liz Earle C&P by my sister and didn't think it was really any better for my skin - certainly not worth the many extra ££ anyway.

The cleanser is the only product from the Radiance range I like though, have not been at all impressed with the other radiance products I've tried.

I ended up getting the radiance one as it was BOGOF. Got the 2 in 1 moisturiser to go with it.

Thanks everyone. I might try the vitamin E one when Ive finished this one.

X x