Liquid eyeliner that doesn't budge

[Dinosaur1991]

I'm after a black liquid/gel eyeliner that doesn't transfer to my upper eyelid. I seem to have really oily eyelids and every eyeliner I've tried just becomes a blurry mess
I'm currently using the Illamasqua presision ink one and that's not to bad but still smudges. Any recommendations?

Another vote for Rimmel liquid eyeliner. I use the non waterproof version and it doesn't move.
If you prefer a pen, then Lancome Artliner. Princess Kate uses it. I've slept in it (don't judge 🙈) and it was perfect nearly 24 hours later!

Quick update...I'm not the OP but have exact same problem. Have bought the MAC lasting liner and...it's fab! Only £14 ish.

I don't do liquid but I do do Collections felt tip pen liner .£2.95 draws a nice straight line and applied after eyeshadow stays put all day . Bargain!