opinions on this skirt please

[lucykate]

the brown one

what do you think?, i really wanted a brown cord a-line one but quite like this, just a bit worried the skirt will be too 'full' iykwim

It's nice, but definitely fuller than a-line.

Good price, too.

well that's definitely not a line. too swishy and flouncy imo. you can do better than that.

funny length imo

mmm not sure -- if you are slim hipped and flat stomached maybe... if you are human, then it could look very frumpy

Yes, if you look like a twig it would be fine, but if you're built like a normal person it would be a touch voluminous. How about something like this Long Cord Skirt ? Top right on my screen.

no I'm not keen either. a-line would definitely be better

so thats a no then?

what about the brown one here instead?

its only £13, common theme here is brown and cheap

lk - that link doesn;t seem to be working

try Gap - they did have knee-length cord a-line skirts with a bit of stretch in brown and olive green reduced to £10 - not sure there'll be any left though...

Hideous.Can't see it flattering anyone.