I'm thinking of trying this next. I'm a smudger, I have tried so many cheap & expensive mascaras but I either get flakes or smudges. I have no oil on my lashes, tried with or without primer but I still smudge. I do live in Australia so maybe it's the heat, though it still happened in the UK. Tubing mascara still flake on me & I hate rubbing my lashes to remove it. I'm hoping the Bobbie Brown one will be good.