Best liquid eyeliner?

[Oceanpurple]

I'm looking for a new eyeliner - have never sought out a good eyeliner before and have used numerous rubbish ones. I wear a lot of benefit makeup and was thinking of buying the 'they're real' push up one, but the reviews are mediocre. Anyone have any good recommendations? Good for doing winged eyeliner and that stays for a long time? Thanks!

The Stila eyeliner pens available at M&S are the best.

I second Collection 2000. It is absolutely amazing. I use both their 'Extreme 24 Hour Felt Tip Liner' and the one in the little ink type pot. Fast Stroke? I paid House of Fraser several visits and had Benefit, Dior etc and so on all put on (professionally) but still think that the Collection 2000 is better. The price is obviously a tenth, but not just that, it really stays put.

I bought all four colours of Extreme 24 hr by Collection 2000, reduced to £2.50 I think in Superdrug, along with a truly lucious thick eyeshadow pencil (softer than Mac)
I have tried them all tonight, really nice.
Cant get it off, but really nice!

Another vote for Collection 2000 here! I've been using it for the last 4 years and have never found a better one.

Normally I use premium brands but this stuff is fantastic

I second the loreal super liner one it's got real staying power

Got Collection 2000 and it's amazing! Also got Nars stylo but C2000 is just as good - if not better.

Which C2000 did you go for? The felt tip liner or the little pot?

The felt tip ones

Is the C2000 Extreme 24he waterproof please?

Soap and Glory Supercat

NotagainMum I don't think it's waterproof but it is hard to get off !