Clinique Naturally Glossy mascara giving me panda eyes

[OuterFromOutersville]

It comes off onto the skin under my eyes, and accumulates in my fine lines , accentuating them.

Does anyone have any alternative suggestions?

I got that with the Max Factor 2000 calories one

I am now wearing (as an experiment) the one from Boots Natural Collection ( Waterguard) . It cost me £1.50 and it is excellent- can't believe how much I have spent on mascara in the past

I've been through just about every waterproof mascara going and the only one I've had any success with is the blinc amplifying mascara which I buy from their site. It's not 100% perfect but it's certainly the best I've ever used. Each tube lasts for ages which is just as well as it's a bit ££. Though they do send out enough discount offers to keep me going through the year. Their pencil eyeliner however, is pretty useless. I had high hopes for it but it caused the dreaded panda eyes.

I got that mascara in a GWP once and it did exactly the same to me. I like all of the Estee Lauder mascaeas, except the waterproof one, and all of the Lancome mascaras too.

I will definitely try the Boots Naturals collection one next.