Can't decide on handbag please help me choose

[BumWad]

I have a few on my list but keep flitting between what I want! I love cross body bags, so a long strap is essential. It is for work (not office based so doesn't have to be formal) and light travelling (need 1 change of clothes without shoes to fit in). I'm a massive fan of Fossil bags and my local outlet has some heavily discounted ones...

Fossil 1 really worried the cream leather is going to get filthy

Fossil 2 this is my original love, saw it in the Manchester store full price just before Christmas, it's now half price.

Modalu I can't really afford this but I bloody love it. My mum says she'll open an account for me to get the best discount but it's still quite high. Not sure if the blue is too garish?

Fossil 3 this is the bargain of the lot, I think it's quite cute but it's not leather just fabric

I must add that I change bags pretty frequently which is also why I'm reluctant in spending money on the modalu one. Thank you!

I like the modalu one best FYI my friends have just bought me an osprey bag in a similar colour and shape to option one from tk maxx for £59 (it would have originally retailed for 265) so it might be worth a look there.

Thank you cloud for liking the most expensive one!

Bumping for more opinions please

Modalu!

Modalu too, sorry!

Think first one will quickly look grubby.
Like number two.
Cannot open the link to 3rd fossil bag
Modalu is the nicest.

Modalu

The first one.The others are rank (sorry!)

I like Fossil 3 and the modalu one. I have the modalu one in another colour and size and I keep opening and closing sections to find things so you need to be more organised than me or use it all the time so you get to put things in the same place all the time. It also weighs a tonne. Looks good though.

The cream one is nice but not very practical for everyday use. I like the style of the others but not keen on blue for a handbag. Just go for the one you like best even if it's the most expensive. I always seem to like the most expensive thing for some reason.

Another vote for the modalu, it's lovely.

I've got that Modalu in black, it is lovely. But mine was a lot cheaper when I bought it last year from John Lewis.

www.tkmaxx.com/view-all-accessories/nude-paneled-bag/invt/11767769?VBMST=modalu

local tkmaxx store has more choices than shown on website, bargainous

i like the very first one! Would always be worried about dirt though

I like fossil 2, I like the first one but don't think it will sit very well cross body.

I have the larger size pippa and wouldn't expect to be able to put all that much in it, so doubt the mini one would be big enough.

Thank you all!

Went to get Fossil 2 but ended up with this one:

Fossil Maddox it's an older style but the leather felt so much nicer and loved the colour and classic style, it's a bit lighter than navy blue even though it says dark purple

The link says the listing is no longer in use. I googled it but different ones came up. Is it the one with large flap over?

This one!

Lovely