never mind mutton willi look like a bit of goat....

[MeMyElfandI]

Ladies , opinions needed on these boots. They are navy suede and do look better in real life.

www.marksandspencer.com/Autograph-Suede-Water-Resistant-Insolia%C2%AE/dp/B002ZP6NV8?ie=UTF8&ref=sr_1_16&nodeId=3154819031&sr=1-16&qid=1391886742

I'm 48 size 18 and 5'8''

Will i look like mutton or even worse are they mum bootish?

they will be ok depending on what you wear with them. Avoid bootlegs and fleeces and you should be fine

They are nice.

in saying that though, a smaller heel would probably look better

I prefer these if you're going down the M&S path...
here

I think they are a little bit frumpy, I think it's the heel.