3 different jumper tops- which one would be most useful?

[fruitcorner]

I have bought/ordered 3 different jumpers and not sure which I should keep as now feel extravagant - which is going to be most useful? They are all for going out and about in but not work
www.jigsaw-online.com/products/cashmere-mix-swing-sweater-6905
www.hush-uk.com/sale/daywear_1/amy_dress_marine.htm
www.thewhitecompany.com/sale/clothing/sleeveless-cocoon-jumper--grey-marl/?awc=4802_1389738976_20f03601e18d8f629624ab83ad710674&CM_MMC=Affiliates--AWIN--Autumn2012-_-text&ProGrpCode=AW12 on order

I like the Amy dress best

Id keep the grey.

I like the first one.

I like the grey

The grey one might get it myself

The jigsaw or white company one, not fussed on the hush one, funny length and fit IMO. I really like the grey one.

Jigsaw
Grey is a shapeless blob

Can't comment on hush phone is refusing to display it properly.

The White Company one. Tempted to buy it too!

Amy if you've got the figure/bought it big enough
I like the jigsaw one
The White Company one is like a sack (like most of their stuff this winter)

The Hush one. Not keen on the other two - too shapeless.

I like the white conpaby one. The jigsaw one is a really odd shape - that much volume around the hips would make anyone look fatter. And the proportions of the hush one are a bit odd - it should have longer sleeves or be shorter - as it is it doesn't look quite right.

first and grey one.

but I like the red so if it's volume that's a problem I'd try to find a nice other red jumper...

also will it be out and about and is it needed for warmth or can you get away with short sleeves re the White Company one?

that's what I think of...

I like the first one from jigsaw

I don't think the dress will wear well (too likely to go out of shape/bobbly) and is less versatile than a sweater, grey is meh...red is lovely, great colour and flattering cut. Definitely the winner for me.

I disagree with the posters saying the red will make wearer look big, with a slim fitting skirt/skinny jeans the contrast in wide top/slim bottom will make you look smaller

The Amy dress.

I can't see the jigsaw one but I like the amy dress out of the other two.