Honest opinions of these boots.

[SeaDevilscanPlay]

These

What do you think? Too ott to wear with skinny trousers?

Or these?

I prefer second pair. I have seen the first pair and I don't like them. DM's are really, really comfy though.

the second pair. First look a little like an elf's costume.

i really like the first ones, bit different

I like them both.

I like the Red or Dead pair.

Definitely the first ones.Nothing OTT about them, they would look great with black skinny jeans.
I'm considering going back to wearing DM's after 25 years of not owning a pair.

The first ones. Definitely. I got some amazing dms last year, like those but with one buckle and in purple and they are super comfy and look fab with skinny jeans.

I love them both

I like them both, not a helpful comment I realise.

Second by a country mile, but that's my personal taste: I really dislike DMs.

I have a pair of the first ones in black from Schuh and they are lovely and comfy and look great under trousers and with skinnys. I would like another pair in mahogany but they have sold out. If you are a half size go down. I am a 5.5 but the 6 was too big.

I really like both pairs, possibly prefer the second pair, but only just.

Either, but not red or brown.

Black or purple.

I love the first ones - and they are feather beds for feet.

What about these?

I like the first pair - the straps on the second pair are too big. I don't like the red, I would get black or brown.

I am buying the first pair :)

Second by miles for me!

First. DM's are so comfy!!

First pair but not red.

First.

Spent ages finding some boots without the three pirate straps this year!

Actually first ones are fine too if not red- it was that that was putting me off. DMs do look very comfy.

Not my kind of thing either of them sorry. But if you like them then that's all that matters.

Not the first. They remind me of the safety boots worn by forklift truck drivers.

Second pair mighty cool.
First pair, meh.