New handbag, narrowed down to two choices

[mashpot]

Hello,
I've been looking for a new handbag for my Christmas pressie and saw two yesterday that I like the look of, anyone feel like casting a vote on which they'd go for?

www.whistles.co.uk/fcp/product/whistlesduffy-zip-satchel/903000061096

www.selfridges.com/en/Bags/Categories/NEW-IN/Women/Cobble-Hill-Little-Curtis-cross-body-bag_133-3003424-PXRU4231001/?previewAttribute=Black

Ta!

The Whistles one! Much nicer!

I like the Kate Spade one.

I like the Kate Spade one.

Sorry double post. iPad gone a bit funny.

Whistle one looks like a nice shape. The Kate Spade one looks a little ordinary in my opinion.

Kate spade one is lovely the other one would put me into panic if it got dirty !

Sorry, neither.

Both look a bit grannyish.

See any here you like...

www.theoutnet.com/Shop/Bags/Shoulder_Bags?sortBy=price-asc

Out of those 2 I prefer the whistles one but having said that I have just bought a Kate Spade from the same range but this one which I think shape wise is much nicer
kate spade

The Kate Spade one.

The one justasecond linked to is much nicer.

I like justa's link better than your 2, OP, sorry.

The Kate Spade one [tchsmile]

Ooh thanks all for opinions. Maybe I have grannyish taste! I really like the other Kate Spade too just but its more expensive and a bit over budget. So, I'm not sure posting has helped my decision making at all!

Like the Kate Spade.