Are these shoes gorgeous or am I blinded by the name?

[MichelleRouxJnr]

I think I want these for my autumn shoes.
DH thinks I'm seeing them through Rosie-tinted glasses (I'm a Rosie):

www.schuh.co.uk/womens-Tan-Red-Or-Dead-Rosie/1373186220/?s_kwcid=PTC&type=&cid=GOOG_PLA&keyword=&matchype=&adwords_prod=46571983151&network=g&mobile=&creative=21383523071&gclid=CNne_Ie_zrkCFbHItAodgBkAZQ#ReviewsSection

What do you people with much better tatse than me think?
Ty

I think these are sweet, lovely brogues and might be my next shoe purchase!

I thought they were men's shoes.

I almost bought these but when I saw them in 'real life' the clarks hambles are so much nicer, the R or D ones looked like they had a curly-up toe in the shop.

I love a good brogue and have been really happy with my clarks. Might be worth having a look at both?

You've made me feel much happier Freudian.

I like brogues but they are far too mannish.

They cant possibly be ladies shoes can they?

Do you all regularly get mistaken for men then? Cos when I wear brogues with a jersey pencil skirt, or wide leg trousers and a silk blouse I definitely don't look mannish!

Lovers of stylish flats might enjoy the En Brogue blog.

I like the Dotty P ones better. I used to have similar many years ago (nearly 30!!). The Red or Dead ones are too clumpy around the toe for my liking and do look far more like men's shoes.

Oh no, they are very masculine. Not my cup of tea.

They are truely hideous.........

Ooh I really like these! I quite like a bit of an androgynous look anyway... Am quite tempted actually!