Which of these coats would you rather have? Just looks-wise...Thanks!

[LeoandBoosmum]

www.hobbs.co.uk/images/products/0213-3718-1637L00-1767/0213-3718-1637L00-1767_01_470_505.jpg
or
www.hobbs.co.uk/images/products/0212-3746-3893L00-1182/0212-3746-3893L00-1182_01_470_505.jpg

The non-quilted one for me.

Second one.
Not keen on quilted fabric of first, bit old-fashioned?

Second one by about a million miles. I have seen quilted done well and looking fresh and wearable. That is not it.

Second, definitely!

The first one is hideous. The second is much better, but too fussy and flappy around the waist and pockets, so I think it would add bulk. I like the colour though.

Sorry, not keen on either, but if I had to choose, it would be the second one.

Second one.. First looks to be for the older lady.