Boring but necessary... brown liquid eye-liner, please help!

[PeggyGuggenheim]

For years I used a Boots No. 7 brown liquid eye-liner which was fine , but when I went to replace it last year , I found the new tube was incredibly claggy and thick, unusable. So I'm loathe to buy it again..but am conflicted because it really was a good eyeliner. Has anyone suffered this problem? Maybe it was a bad batch.
My requirements:
-Brown
-Liquid
-Waterproof because I have a hot face and everything melts!
Thank you and apologies for banal posting !

Oooh I was having exactly this issue today! Going through my old make up and deciding what to ditch etc.

So, I used Prestige's dark brown liner for ages and ages, not officially waterproof but never budged and cheap. Also liked the brush.

Now use Body Shop brown/black liner. Ditto on waterproofness.

I actually just threw out a No 7 liner as it was much worse than those other two.

compare.ebay.co.uk/like/200891250660?var=lv&ltyp=AllFixedPriceItemTypes&var=sbar&adtype=pla&crdt=0

Googled - this is the Prestige one.

www.thebodyshop.co.uk/make-up/eyes/liquid-eyeliner.aspx?cm_mmc=FusePump--GoogleShopping--TagMan-_-Link&gclid=CO7OyJH0mLYCFYfJtAodiHIA6Q

Body Shop one.

Rimmel have a brown liquid eyeliner. I buy the one with the felt tip pen style applicator rather than brush.

Thanks ladies ! Someone else recommend the Rimmel to me so I think I might give that a go.. thanks again

I like the Rimmell liquid one.

Rosie