smude/waterproof eye liner gel or pencil

[bulletproofgerbil]

Any recommendations? I've just consigned the body shop's waterproof pencil to the bin on the grounds that it smudges within a few hours. I am hopeless with liquid liner so would need either a pencil or a gel that I could apply with slanted brush. TIA

Bare Minerals do a waterproof eyeliner that seems to stay put all day for me! here

Thanks Mumelie. Would never have thought of Bare Minerals. I use a lot of lili lolo products and they haven't got anything like that. I;m going to give this one a shot. The price isn't too bad either.

Bobbi brown gel liner - you apply with a brush it won't budge

Maybelline gel liner. Comes with brush that's pretty good. Cheap and different colours
Or urban decay 24/7 pencils - I did a 15hr shift and it didn't move (may have also slept in it)

This one! -> Estee Lauder Double Wear eye pencil

It's the biz! I've just bought one in graphite shade, as recommended on here and I love it - it really does last all day; looks as fresh at tea time as it does in the morning. Love the little smudger end too. Perfect if you want a smoky kohl effect that doesn't vanish after a couple of hours.

Thank you everyone. So many suggestions. Don't know which to try first now.:)