Opinions on benefit They're Real mascara please

[Ashoething]

I have been tempted to try this a couple of times but the price puts me off! I have very sparse fair lashes and usually use a Loreal one-have tried Lancome and clinique ones too and they were crap.

Boots are selling a mini version of They're Real for a tenner though-any ladies on here tried it yet?

Awful. Don't waste your money.

I bought it at xmas and genuinely couldn't believe how shit it was. Watery consistency, made my (longish and full-ish) lashes stick together in a lovely skinny finger fashion. Yuck.

Donated it to my mother and returned to Max Factor 2000 Calories aka the best mascara in the world.

Thanks for the heads up bunny-will save my cash. I started a thread on here for you the other day and you ignored me-I got the Pearl lowe red lace dress off ebay for £20!

Oh no! I didn't see! Sorry

Good bargain though! I've been wearing my Peggy at every available opportunity

Yep I still want the Peggy too but its still going for crazy money-the red one was brand new too with tags on! I was outbid on one the week before too! I have a weekend with friends next month so planning on wearing it then-just need to get shoes now!

I see you've already made your decision, but just wanted to say it's the most SHITE mascara I've ever used.

The Benefit They're Real mascara works really well for lots of people though. I really like the effect it gives, don't find it watery or clumpy. It does dry out quicker than most mascara's, in the tube though, and for that reason I wouldn't repurchase. I recommend Revlon's Grow Luscious (green tube) as an alternative.

Hi i found they're real really great!
i think its the best mascara ive tried, and at £18 it is quite a punt.
really nice length, not too clumpy, really black, doesnt flake at all during the day.
give it a go! (tho super nice MIL did buy my last one tho!)

I really like it.

I know I sound daft but it makes my eye lids really heavy!! Do think it looks nice for and evening etc. it does take me back to being a teenager and having spider eyes though from layer upon layer of mascara.

Try it on at the counter. I didnt like it, it made me look like I had about 8 spidery lashes.

I really like it too. Not that I wear it often.

My favourite mascara for thick, sooty lashes is Mally Beauty.
I did get seduced by the They're Real, but not impressed.
It seems to work better for me if I use one coat only otherwise it clogs them up.
(Not that my eyelashes are anything to get excited about though )