Anyone have the Clinique chubby sticks?

[gregssausageroll]

Are they any good?

I always chicken out of buying one in case the sales assistant laughs at the chubby girl buying a chubby stick watching with interest to see if they're worth the potential ridicule

I have 2 and I have to say, I am very disappointed with them. They are overpriced for what they are- they have the longevity of a lip balm. Nice choice of colours, but I would rather pay a pound more and buy one of the Clarins Joli Rouge Brilliants, as they are sheer but last much, much longer. The idea of the chubby stick is good and they look nice, but they don't deserve all the plaudits that they seem to be getting at the moment!

I like them. I am a Clinique fan generally. I had a pink one which looked nice. Currently have a nude shade and a red one.
I am a skinny short arse so can't comment on possibility of chubby laughter ;-)

I have a natural pink one and it's a bit meh, I think they're overpriced for what they are, I think Revlon or someone does a cheaper, and better, alternative.

The Revlon ones are lovely.
Apparently Clinique will be bringing out a new version later - Intense or something.

i really like them. I have 2. fishes in bag. super strawberry - had to stop dd running off with it :)

I think you may be a bit paranoid there nappybag. But you might like this :)

I like mine - I got one in a clinique freebie (which is one of those freebies which is worth it, a bag, pink chubby stick, pink blusher, mascara, eye cream, make up remover, liquid soap). But to be honest it is exactly the same as my pink tinted Carmex lipbalm which cost £4.

I like the packaging of it - but wouldn't pay much for it, I think No 17 does a similar product.

I have so many of those little mascaras, they never give away the one that I actually like.

Clinique too light and no lasting power at all. Revlon version half the price and twice as good.

trills
But yes, I'm definitely paranoid. I can't even order a diet coke without feeling like a fraud

The Revlon one is excellent

Could you link the revlon one?

Another vote for Revlon here. In fact I like a lot of their makeup. Even the long lasting foundation is pas mal indeed, doublewear light it is not, but a good second.

I have one but don't like it, it just doesn't look right. I love their lip plumping glosses though. Revlon lip butter a cheaper alternative

Are they similar to the 17 Mirror Shine lippies? The reason I ask is the Revlon lip butters are supposed to be the same as 17.

I have several of the 17 ones, they are really good, and at the moment buy one, get one half price (around £4.50 each)