Please give opinions on these boots- Clarks.

[MissBoPeep]

Have recently bought some calf-high chunky biker boots but although some of my trousers are skinny-ish they look a bit baggy tucked in. So am looking for some boots to wear under the trousers.

www.clarks.co.uk/p/20354364

www.clarks.co.uk/p/20354349

Which of these do you prefer?

If they are just for wearing under trousers then the first ones are probably better as the buckles/laces on the second pair may look lumpy under your trousers.

Hmmm. Even if the trousers are narrow/straight legs? I'm talking about denims and straight leg cords. But I am listening!

The bits and pieces on the second pair would certainly show as bumps under my skinny trousers - and they aren't skin tight. Think the first would be much better for this purpose - in fact tempted to try them myself.

I love the second pair, but for under trousers, would go with the first pair.

I like the first pair. In fact they're quite similar to a pair I was looking at in John Lewis.

I also like these but they don't look as nice quality as the Clarks ones.

Is it the norley cedar that you have? I have seen the shorted version the norley woods worn with skinny and straight legs jeans, they kind of just sit on top of the boots.

Yes- and they are also very stiff and a bit heavy to wear - maybe they will soften up. I wish there was a 20% somewhere.

I like the first pair.